I am currently nearing the end of the life on my no-name all season tires. I am back and forth between replacing them with Goodyear Wrangler Duratrac tires in the 33x12.50r15 size*, BFG KM2 tires in the 33x10.50r15 size** or Toyo Open Country MT tires in the 33x10.50r15 size***. I have in the past had 35" Pro Comp mud terrains on another vehicle, but they were not impressive to me. I used a set of Toyo Open Country ATs that were nice for an all terrain on the same "other vehicle".
I off road enough to appreciate the self cleaning ability and bite of a mud terrain tire, but at the same time use my rig as a daily driver. It looks like the Goodyear Wrangler Duratrac is a a nice combination of off road capable and on road usable. The only problem I have with the Duratrac is that it only comes in a 12.5" width for the 33" diameter size. I am only mildly lifting my 2nd gen 4Runner and do not know if a 33x12.50 tire will fit. I am leaning towards a 33x10.50 tire size, and to that end there are two excellent mud terrain tires offered: the BFG KM2 and Toyo Open Country MT. Either one will do what I need it to do off road, and either one is acceptable on road. While I think the Goodyear Wrangler Duratrac is the best fit for me, the sizes offered may force me to go a different route.
*Goodyear Wrangler Duratrac tire, 33x12.50r15 size on 15x8 rims shown on a gen 2 4Runner (the picture is from Off Road and 4x4 magazine website)
**BFG KM2 tire, 33x10.50r15 on a Toyota pickup
***Toyo Open Country MT, size unknown and shown unmounted on a vehicle
While I am not currently running any of these tires, I will eventually be running one of them. I'll check back in to the thread with pictures of them mounted on my rig.