I will be towing a 3.5K lb pop up camper, so I'm pretty sure I would average higher in the v8 than the v6. At altitude and mountain passes, the v6 would strain pretty hard. I will keep my v8 thanks very much.
I think you are probably right.
This past weekend I attended an Antique Car Meet in the Finger Lakes Region of upstate New York. My route involved climbing a few hills between 2-3K feet high.
I have to wonder how a V6 would have done pulling my loaded, enclosed car trailer on that trip. Oh wait, I would not have done that since the V6 is not rated for over 5K lbs.
At one rest stop I noticed two Porsches on open car trailers.
When I left the rest stop I was able to see the tow vehicles being used and their drivers. One tow vehicle was a Porsche Cayenne and the other was a 4Runner.
I found it interesting that both drivers gave me a somewhat odd look when I passed them pulling my trailer. Were they wishing they had an enclosed trailer or were they wondering how a 4Runner could pull one? When I glanced in my mirrors I did not see a "V8" badge on the 4Runner so I do have to wonder.
BTW, on my way home from that meet on Sunday I can back through those same hills. This time it was a little more interesting with the Heavy Rain and High, Gusty, Winds. Made me ever so glad I have the dual cam sway control. Driving in those conditions without it would have been dangerous to say the least.
When I got home I came to find out that there were multiple tornado watches along my whole route home and in places those "gusty" winds were a lot higher than I have towed through in the past.
FYI, my calculated mileage for the trip was 9.14 mpg based on three fuel fill ups. Pretty good MPGs considering the hills, wind and load I was towing.
Back on topic....
I have found that my MPG sweet spot with my V8 is around 45-55 mph.
In that range I have seen 20-21 MPG (calculated).