Ok, so from bad to worse. I checked all of the unbundled wires I could find and everything looks fine, but it seems there is more wrong than the turn signal. The horn stopped working, the liftgate window stopped working, and that's just what I'm aware of on top of the left turn signal.
The only change I can think of to the factory wiring is the HID's I just installed, but the only tampering with the factory wiring is that you add the ballasts and instead of plugging in both head light receivers you only plug one in to the HID kit. I tried unplugging it but no change. I can't let it stay like this so I'm going to a shop this week, but any last ditch ideas would be appreciated.
What I've done so far:
Checked the wiring to and from the turn signals
Replaced the turn signal bulb
replaced the front, passenger side turn signal (the plug was damaged)
Added an additional 6 awg ground wire from the battery (had it lying around and figured if I was browning out it was worth a shot)