I went with the AVS. I ran into 2 issues with them. The 3M tape they came with ended up pulling off of both the guards and window frame within a month. This was resolved with a new roll of 3M double side tape, I removed them, put on the new tape, reattached and they haven't budged in over 2 years now. The other issue is very minor hairline fracturing, on both sides, at the base of the front windows (next to the mirror). Not enough of a crack to separate entirely, and you really can't notice them unless you're really looking, but the first few times you roll up the windows, you may here some crunching.