The last six or seven cars we have bought have been Mercedes or BMW. Most recently, I had a six month old BMW that spent almost two of those months in the shop. As the clock was ticking toward lemon territory, I test drove a few other luxury SUVs, all fine cars, but none of them excited me. Then I came across one of those articles on the web "Cars Most Likely to make it to 400,000 miles" or something like that. The 4R was top of the list. I'd always liked them, but thought it would be a "downgrade". Had a free afternoon and test drove one on a whim. Felt an immediate emotional connection to the thing for some reason. In the weeks that followed, lurked here on the forums and you guys convinced me it would be a good decision. BMW opted to give me a replacement vehicle for the lemon instead of just buying back the old one. I drove it for a couple of weeks while I waited on the registration, etc. and then traded it in with 400 miles on it for my 4R.
Haven't regretted it a bit!