Hi Spish! Such a personal preference question!
In order I wanted:
4x4
moonroof
neutral exterior color
preferable:
metallic interior bezels and accompanying sport hood
cloth - wouldn't mind leather if it was great condition but I live in the south like you and the whole sweaty butt factor of leather doesn't turn me on.
These alone narrowed me down to just a few years....
Then it was the standard carfax/autocheck, mileage, interior condition, maintenance records, and locational history that wasn't in a known road salting state.
A note on all the carfax / maintenance records issue - seriously, buying used is almost ALWAYS a crapshoot - you are going to be one lucky SOB to find something that doesn't need some work - the trick is not getting upside down in value. I owned my 2nd gen for 18 years before this one, and I took GOOD care of that - pull my Carfax you wont find much...not even my dealer services...they aren't the end all be all. Just accept that its going to need work and do as much due diligence as you can to know what you are investing in. Best thing about them is that you can identify a WRECK...but guess what? My new one definitely had a paint job - who knows what they covered up.
I budgeted 1k off the bat for repairs, then found something that would fit my budget. Bought it sight unseen and had it shipped.
If I was doing it NOW I would have added manual transmission, nixed the 01-02 for the stupid electronic throttle control & VSC, and looked a little harder for the rear locker.
Every time I floor it I get pissed at my throttle control. :wtf:
If I had been in person looking at it these are the things I would have looked at:
At delivery I immediately had to do rear axle seals - this is a good thing to look for - look at the back side of rear tires for evidence of grease....for that matter...look at all the suspension components around interior of wheels for what looks like loss of grease or major looking rust / rot
If it has a history of being in a snowing area, while you are under there pull the bellcranks on rear interior of wheels to see if they are seized
If you can get it lifted during inspection, wiggle wheels 9-3 o'clock and 6-12 o'clock
Have someone drive behind you when you test drive to see if its dog tracking looking like slighty sideways gate.
When you are test driving stomp the brakes - is there a shimmy?
Crank the wheel all the way each direction and do a circle preferably hitting a bump along the way and listen for unusual noises or pops
open the hood and put your finger in the middle expanse of the belts - do they have more than 1"-1.5" - of play?
Is there evidence of grime accumulation anywhere indicating a fluid leak?
Does the engine look like it was just steam cleaned to hide something?
What color is the coolant?
look at and smell tranny fluid
look at oil
look at battery - wiggle terminals
identify all breaches of wiring in firewall and inspect seals
look for a sticker showing timing belt change with date and mileage (under hood)
test all electronics including electronic door locks and power antenna
Check all door handles including the key functioning in all exterior cylinders easily
look at trim package. Does it match up with what was available?
look to match vin on all door jams
That's all I can think of...Thank you for serving!