weekendclimber
New member
Don't torque it to the FSM spec. Just use your best judgement and get it snug with a 3/8" ratchet.
^^^This. I had to remove another stuck plug (2nd time in a year) recently that I had tightened per the Toyota specs on a new diff from ECGS. Even with a brand new diff, with clean surfaces, and torque properly, it was stuck. After getting it out, I didn't have a replacement plug (it was a month before I was able to get back under there and put an new plug in), so just tightened the stripped one back in with the extractor I used to get it out. I bet that extractor only put, maybe, 10 ft/lbs on it. When I pulled it a month later, it was on there tight! I think maybe 20 ft/lbs on that thing is more than enough to keep it from going anywhere.