4th gen VS. 5th gen - my thoughts

Quantum

New member
Hi All,

Again, thanks for such a warm welcome to the forum!

I know this topic has been talked about A LOT! In fact you guys helped me when I was looking but I thought since I finally have a 2013 TE I thought I would give you my first impressions in case others find it useful.

First off, it took about 2 months to get the thing once I put a deposit down. Apparently they are not easy to come by in the Boston area. I even had a friend of mine who works for Toyota try to locate one for me with no luck. He did come in handy later when we did find one because he could get into the allocation system and tell me that it "was still on the boat somewhere in the ocean" - for about a month!

I honestly don't remember my very first thoughts when I drove my first 4Runner back in 2000 other than I loved it. However when I bought my 4th gen 2006 in November of 2005 I remember, vividly, thinking "Oh my God, this thing feels like a car!". Then 2 weeks ago when I first drove my 5th gen 2013 I thought, "Oh my God, this thing drives like a truck!" Which is a very good thing!

My 2000 felt like I could get through anything. In winters (back when New England got a lot of snow on a regular basis) I remember other cars and trucks shoveling out of 18" snow storms, slipping and sliding off the road, stuck etc. My 2000 was a beast and I never had to dig the thing out, it would just power through whatever I put in front of it. I did not do too much off roading with it, mostly tame stuff but there were a few times... It performed amazingly well and was a solid truck. The 3rd gens, as you all know had part time 4X4. At the time, I did not know the difference...it just worked.

My 4th gen 2006 was a great truck in many, many ways. It was a very comfortable ride and had nice interior features like the leather wrapped steering wheel, automatic climate control and overall decent interior materials. However I never felt like it was a beast or that it could get through anything. The 4X4 system always felt weak somehow like it was not fully engaged somehow. I know a lot of you guys are going to disagree with that, but it was just my impression of it. Sure, there were upsides to it being full time 4X4 because you could turn it on (with a dial, I hated a dial) and not think about it. But when you got in the sh** it just fell so short for me. In fact I got it stuck, more than once in both snow and dirt. The snow was pretty deep but I had the mind set of my last 4runner and thought it could handle it. Overall I did love the truck. It drove like a sports car (relatively) and I could whip the thing around and I got to know it intimately so I knew what it could and could not do. It was also fast for an truck. I remember stomping on it for the first time and thinking "holy sh**, this thing moves!" I think it was a great truck, served me well and I truly enjoyed it and was sad to see it go, I really was!

Fast forward to December 2013. Now, I have only had the 5th gen for a couple of weeks but I feel like there are just so many things that make the truck different, I feel like I can give a good preliminary review.

As I said, when I first drove it I thought that it felt like a truck. I felt like I was back in a 4runner, a true on off road beast (stock of course, in both versions - I am being a bit dramatic). But there is a stark difference in the feel of both trucks. The 5th gen is taller, bigger, roomier and has a much more solid feel - while moving, mind you. I know it is not that much bigger but it certainly give the feeling that it is. Like others have talked about here there are some drawbacks to the 5th gen. I have read people debate back and fourth regarding the engine, power and speed of the 5th gen. I honestly do not have it figured out yet. What I can tell you is that there is a substantial difference in the feel if nothing else. In the 4th gen, when you step on it, you did not have to go to far and you were moving. If you wanted to get on it and go, it did not take much and if you really wanted to move, floor it and you were going! The 5th gen is very different. It can feel like a dog sometimes. I find myself really having to push the throttle just to get moving out into traffic. Even this morning, merging on to 95, on a slight hill, there was a car beside me who was slowing down to let me in. I pushed further and further on the throttle and eventually had to floor it just to get out in front of him. Now, maybe I did not have to do that, but it sure felt like I had to. On the other hand I have thought maybe the throttle is just set up differently than the 4th gen. There are many times where if I just push the throttle further than I think (or remember from the 4th gen) I should, it moves just fine. I am leaning towards that thinking because I have a feeling I just need to get used to it. Also I can see (if that is true) why Toyota would make the throttle less sensitive for off roading.

The interior is good, not great, good. It is obvious that Toyota put the money into components and systems in the truck vs. a "pretty" interior. The leather wrapped steering wheel is gone, the automatic climate control is gone. The dash and other areas of the truck feel somewhat cheap. Even the doors feel noticeably cheaper - approaching tin can sound and feel when opening and closing the doors.

However, having said all of that, I love this generation of the 4runner! It is a solid riding, beast feeling machine that was built for tough situations. Everyday driving is improved (minus the engine performance - although the jury is still out on that). You feel the road when you drive and with the KDSS, you hug the road and trails like I have not experienced in a 4Runner. The crawl control and multi terrain select is fantastic and gets you out of situations that the 4th gen would be left spinning its wheels.

I am very happy that the part time 4x4 is back. In my opinion (I know I am going to catch it for this), it is far superior to full time 4X4. I have read people talk about never using it on dry pavement. I whole heartily disagree with that. I drove my 3rd gen in 4X4 all the time on dry/snowy pavement - for miles - on the highway - on side streets - everywhere when I needed it - for 6 years and never had a problem, not one. It is true that the diff will bind in sharp corners like a parking lot, pulling out of the driveway or tight turns on small streets. You just have to be aware of what you are doing and think about it to make sure you don't over steer and bind it up. Maybe I am totally wrong about this but all I can tell you is that I live in New England and need 4X4 quite a bit and I never, ever had a problem.

So those are my initial thoughts. Wow, that was kind of long...sorry. Again, overall I absolutely love the 5th gen and would not trade it for any other version. The difference is that this is an on/off road machine and there will be compromises for that, that I talked about. If you are looking for a more "creature comfortable" version then the 4 gen is for you. If you are looking for something that will perform in tough conditions then the 5th gen is your truck.

Thoughts, criticisms, "you are out of your mind" comments....

Quantum
 
Register to hide this ad
Great write up/initial review. This is my first 4Runner - and BOF SUV - since I was in college (a 1991 Jeep Wrangler ...yes, dating myself there). Had never considered a 4Runner until 5th gens came out - and the styling got me. Yes, it's truckish, but also enough lux/nice-to-haves to be valeted without giggles (if valeting is your thing). Think it's a great overall balance. My youngest calls it the zombie crusher ... though it's no where near what others in this forum have done.

You're 3rd and 4th gen perspective make me better understand the criticisms laid out on the 5th gen.

Re: this ...

In the 4th gen, when you step on it, you did not have to go to far and you were moving. If you wanted to get on it and go, it did not take much and if you really wanted to move, floor it and you were going! The 5th gen is very different. It can feel like a dog sometimes. I find myself really having to push the throttle just to get moving out into traffic.

Agreed the 4R can leave you flat footed if not paying attention. It's certainly not underpowered, but Toyota put MPG ahead of thrills when dialing in the throttle control and gearing. I've found it's best to get on it early, then back off. For example, a I live on a pretty steep hill... always best to punch it at the bottom, vs. after starting up the slope, then back off (tends to hold its gear pretty well that way).

Good luck, be safe, and glad you're here and enjoying your new 5th gen.
 
Thats good advice NW, I found the same thing. I think I am getting more used to the throttle but I am coming to the conclusion that the 5th gen is much more geared for off road than on road. That by it self is not such a bad thing but it really does feel like it is underpowered during on road driving. It's not, but you may have to manually shift into 4th on some hills to keep it moving without having to floor it to force a downshift.

Quantum
 
Thats good advice NW, I found the same thing. I think I am getting more used to the throttle but I am coming to the conclusion that the 5th gen is much more geared for off road than on road. That by it self is not such a bad thing but it really does feel like it is underpowered during on road driving. It's not, but you may have to manually shift into 4th on some hills to keep it moving without having to floor it to force a downshift.

Quantum

It's geared for efficiency and increased mpg on the road.
 
Hi Engineer,

I just started a new thread on gas milage, so good timing on your comment.

With a new set of Firestone Destination AT 265/70 - 17 I am looking at 17 mpg highway/down to 12.7 city. I am driving normally (not stepping on it all the time) and I am getting in the mid 200 miles per tank. It seems insane to me. Any thoughts?
 
Why would you drive your 3rd gen in 4wd on dry pavement? I get using 4wd when needed but on dry pavement I'm not sure I see why.

I'm glad you like the 5th gen since that's probably where I'm headed since the 4th gens just felt like a different truck then my 3rd gen and just seemed a bit soft and more ready for the pavement then the dirt.

I drove a 5th gen last year and it did feel alot more like a truck again like the 3rd gens.
 
I think the OP is getting the "part-time" 4wd system confused with the "multi-mode" offered on some models of 3rd and 4th gen. Multi-mode, I believe is basically a torsen diff allowing you to go between 2wd and 4wd (full time-unlocked) even on dry pavement.

The 5th gen no longer has this multi-mode system, probably due to cost.
 
Last edited:
Why would you drive your 3rd gen in 4wd on dry pavement? I get using 4wd when needed but on dry pavement I'm not sure I see why.

I'm glad you like the 5th gen since that's probably where I'm headed since the 4th gens just felt like a different truck then my 3rd gen and just seemed a bit soft and more ready for the pavement then the dirt.

I drove a 5th gen last year and it did feel alot more like a truck again like the 3rd gens.

I hear you on totally dry pavement. That was not really what I was saying. In other words I would drive on a mix of dry/snow. In many situations where I was driving for an expanded period of time some of the smaller streets I was on were covered with snow and ice then the larger streets were "dry". So instead of shifting back and forth, I would just leave it in 4X4. Highways were sometimes the same. There would be patches of snow/dry for miles and I would leave it in 4X4. Again, I never had a problem driving that way. I did not, however, drive on totally drive pavement in the summer in 4x4 - I only used it when I needed it
 
I think the OP is getting the "part-time" 4wd system confused with the "multi-mode" offered on some models of 3rd and 4th gen. Multi-mode, I believe is basically a torsen diff allowing you to go between 2wd and 4wd (full time-unlocked) even on dry pavement.

The 5th gen no longer has this multi-mode system, probably due to cost.

Hey Chip,

You might be right on the 4th gen. But my 3rd gen absolutely had part time 4x4.
 
I think the OP is getting the "part-time" 4wd system confused with the "multi-mode" offered on some models of 3rd and 4th gen. Multi-mode, I believe is basically a torsen diff allowing you to go between 2wd and 4wd (full time-unlocked) even on dry pavement.

The 5th gen no longer has this multi-mode system, probably due to cost.

The limited model has AWD / 4HI / 4LOW
SR5 / Trail are 2HI / 4HI / 4LOW


Hey Chip,

You might be right on the 4th gen. But my 3rd gen absolutely had part time 4x4.

Limited models have 2HI / AWD / 4HI / 4LOW
All other 4wd models are 2HI / 4HI / 4LOW
 
The main difference is center diff Locked or Free. Bottom line: if center or any other diff is locked then it isn’t recommended for dry pavement.
(4wd)
Multi-mode = H2 - (H4F), (H4L), (L4L)
Part-time = H2 - (H4L, L4L)
Full-time = (H4F), (H4L), (L4L)
 
I am very happy that the part time 4x4 is back. In my opinion (I know I am going to catch it for this), it is far superior to full time 4X4.

I just will never understand why people think this way. I can only believe that they simply don't understand how it works.

With fulltime 4WD (more multi-mode), you can leave it in 4WD all the time if you want. And if you lock the center diff, then it behaves EXACTLY like a part-time 4WD system in 4WD.
 
I just will never understand why people think this way. I can only believe that they simply don't understand how it works.

With fulltime 4WD (more multi-mode), you can leave it in 4WD all the time if you want. And if you lock the center diff, then it behaves EXACTLY like a part-time 4WD system in 4WD.

Hi M1911,

I work in Needham and we have an office in Framingham maybe we should hook up to do some wheeling!

You may be right regarding the center diff lock, that's a good point. As I said before, I do not pretend to be an expert and you guys on this forum show vast amounts of knowledge that has helped me in the past. So thanks for that feedback.
 
But I can still say, with authority, that I drove my 3rd gen part time 4x4 on dry pavement (snow/dry/snow, etc) for 6 years without a problem. So for me it is a matter of using it carefully and thinking about what you are doing and using it when you need to. The opinion that "never use it on dry pavement", I just simply disagree with.
 
It's not the driving on dry pavement that could cause problems with a lockable 4 wheel drive system, it's the tight turning on dry pavement. Regular turns on the highway won't even cause problems. The binding will occur in parking lot situations - pulling into and backing out of parking spots for example. The outside radius tire simply has to travel a longer distance than the inside tire to complete the turn. When this happens, the inside wheel will "bind" or have a resistance to turn the same revolutions as the outside tire. Even then it will not break anything but over time increased stresses on the gearing will weaken the set and eventually you COULD break something by making tight turns on dry pavement in 4WD. I don't give it a second thought if I'm driving on snow and there is a patch of dry pavement for a distance. I just keep it in 4WD. Now, in a tight turn situation it goes to 2WD. Just saying.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,310
Messages
3,554,080
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top