52K Easy Miles, Two Cracked Springs and a $7K Repair Bill – Is My Spacer Lift to Blame?

mstgkillr

Junior Member
I have a 2018 4Runner TRD Pro with only 52,000 easy miles on it. It's my wife's daily driver, and she primarily drives it back and forth to work, approximately 10 minutes each way. It has never been off-roaded, exposed to floodwaters, or involved in an accident.

The only suspension and tire modifications are:
  • 2"/1.5" Cornfed spacer lift
  • LT285/70R17 Nitto Ridge Grapplers
Yesterday, we took it to our local Toyota dealership for a brake job, just 16,000 miles after having new OEM pads and rotors installed. They recommended replacing the front and rear pads and rotors, which didn't particularly surprise me. However, things quickly went downhill from there.

The dealership identified the following additional issues:
  • Both front lower control arm bushings are shot, and they're recommending replacement of both complete lower control arm assemblies.
  • Front sway bar end link bushings need replacement.
  • Both front coil springs are cracked and need replacement.
The dealership is blaming everything on the spacer lift and oversized tires. I don't buy it!

Between the brakes, suspension repairs, oil change, and other fluid changes, the total repair bill is going to exceed $7,000.

I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around this amount of suspension wear on a 4Runner with only 52,000 miles, especially considering how conservatively it's been driven. I understand that rubber bushings deteriorate with age and that modifying the suspension geometry can accelerate wear, but two cracked front coil springs on a vehicle that's never seen a trail?

At this point, I'm trying to decide which direction to go:
  • Option 1: Proceed with the dealership's recommended repairs using OEM components and retain the Cornfed spacers and oversized tires.
  • Option 2: Eliminate the spacers and install aftermarket coil springs that provide a similar amount of lift (if there is one) while retaining the factory TRD Pro shocks and current tires.
  • Option 3: Put the money toward a quality aftermarket suspension system, such as King, Icon, or something comparable, rather than spending thousands on OEM suspension components.
My biggest concern is spending this kind of money only to find myself dealing with the same issues another 40,000–50,000 miles down the road.

I really like the current stance of the vehicle and would prefer to retain it, but not at the expense of reliability, ride quality, or safety. I also don't necessarily need an expensive, high-performance off-road suspension system for a vehicle that's strictly street-driven.

For those of you who have been running spacer lifts and 285s on your fifth-gen 4Runners for years:
  • Have you experienced anything remotely similar?
  • Is this amount of suspension wear at 52,000 miles abnormal?
  • Has anyone else experienced cracked factory TRD Pro coil springs?
  • What aftermarket springs would you recommend to eliminate the spacers while maintaining a similar ride height?

If this were your 4Runner and you were staring at a $7,000 repair bill, what would you do?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
It sounds like you are being scammed. I don't see how a spacer lift can cause springs to crack. Did they show you the cracks? No way would you need new rotors after only 16k miles. Even if true, all that should not add up to $7. More like $1k -$2k.

Also, I wouldn't take it to a dealer. Find a good independent shop.
 
I will say that it definitely needed new brake pads and rotors. I checked those myself, but due to time constraints, I figured I would let the dealership handle it. I just never expected the scope of the repairs to snowball like it did.

I’m not convinced that the lift spacers contributed to any of these issues. And yes, I saw both pictures and videos of the coil springs. They weren't just cracked; they were literally snapped in half. After doing some additional research, it appears that spring failure is somewhat common with the Bilstein TRD Pro coilovers.

I put the brakes on replacing the lower control arms and coilovers until I can determine the best path forward, and I plan on having an independent shop perform the work.

I'd hate to spend the money on another set of OEM Bilstein TRD Pro coilovers only to have them fail again in 30,000–50,000 miles, as several other owners have experienced.

Whatever route I decide to go, I want to maintain or improve upon the factory TRD Pro suspension performance without sacrificing ride quality, reliability, or longevity.

I'm currently considering the following:
  • OEM Bilstein TRD Pro
  • OEM FOX TRD Pro (2019–2024)
  • ICON
  • Bilstein 6112/5160
  • Eibach Stage 2R
  • Others I find
I'm a little overwhelmed by all the options, especially given that this vehicle sees almost exclusively on-road use.

For those who have replaced their factory TRD Pro suspension, which route did you go, and would you do it again?
 
Here's my opinion and it's only that, an opinion.

- Most importantly, $7,000 for the work you outlined is a farce, but expected from a dealer. They likely charge $500 each for lower control arms, $200 each for rotors, and I can't even guess what they want for replacement springs. It's likely $150/hour for labor and i'm sure they quoted you far too much labor time for this work.
- IF it were my vehicle, and I wasn't going to do the work myself, i'd find used springs on facebook marketplace. Lots of people remove the OEM TRD Pro suspension for a improved lift kits. If you can't find solid used, i'd maybe price out the springs new, but talk to a reputable 4WD shop, not the dealership.
- While the vehicle is in the shop having the urgent work done, the spring replacement, i'd ask for an inspection (brakes, suspension, etc), to see if they also find the same problems with LCA bushings, sway bar end links, etc.

Additional information. OEM quality lower control arms can be purchased (in Canada) from Sankei 555 for $250 each. I'm sure a 4WD shop in the USA can find them or another reputable brand for far less than OEM pricing. I've also been able to source Sankei 555 brand replacement lower ball joints for OEM lower control arms, something people always say is difficult to find. Brand new poly bushings and ball joints cost me less than $200 Canadian for parts alone, or for $500 I could have had 2 brand new Sankei 555 lower control arms with rubber bushings.

A daily driver doesn't need any further upgraded suspension over the TRD Pro setup, save your money.

Step 1: Find a good 4WD shop in your area and contact them about the broken springs.
Step 2: Have them inspect the vehicle while replacing the springs.
Step 3: Compare their inspection and repair quote to OEM and go from there.

Good luck!
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,504
Messages
3,551,680
Members
248,203
Latest member
2001ATL
Back
Top