At a crossroads and would appreciate input - new truck?

weezykid

New member
So I have owned my 96 t4r since late '08 with 89k miles and it has been a good ride. Did Tundra 13WL brakes in 2010 as well as new tires. Had to do the headgaskets in '14 at 135k due to the issue with the 96's and did the timing belt/waterpump/fan clutch/belts/hoses/knock sensors/external tranny cooler at the same time. Also I installed new OTRE and ITRE's then as well. Last year I put on new rear control arms, rear Moog springs and new shocks. Although I did Febest bars and shoud've gone Toyota as the bushings are starting to crack.

Over the last few months I did new pads/rotors in the front, new rear shoes and drums just a few weekends ago as well as new endlinks all around. Have been chasing a rear driveshaft issue that has been baffled and frustrated as some may have seen in my other post.

Tuesday, while on my way to work, the tranny decided it wanted some attention as well. It threw a P0753 code and it is in the shop right now as I didnt have the time to work on it. So it is getting a new #1 solenoid and new fluid by a local shop.

The truck will need new tires soon as well as rebuilding the front end. I have never touched the LBJ's, UBJ's, shocks, etc. It will need new tires soon as well. So I still have more $$ that needs to go into the 4runner. But being a FL truck it is in great shape with no rust.

Throughout the last year I have been kicking around the idea of getting a newer car. When I bought this I wanted a Tacoma double cab, but could find a good deal. Came across this 4runner and it was a great deal and I love it. Recently I found an 08 Double cab 4x4 TRD in my price range with 91k and thinking about pulling the trigger.

I know I have put a decent amount of money in the 4runner recently and trading it in I wont get it back. The newer truck also means a car payment which I havent had in the last 3-4 years. However it would be really nice to have a newer truck with 70k less miles and a very clean, dealer maintained, CarFax.

Any thoughts are appreciated. Anyone do the same and regret it? Or stay with their 4runner and regret it?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Insurance difference and total cost of ownership. Dont let emotions dictate, then again life is short do both
 
So it's a 1996 and you've had it for 8 years? I'd say you've had a good run. Time to upgrade. Go for the Tacoma and enjoy the additional HP and lower miles. I'm sure you'll love it. If you sell the 4Runner privately you'll almost always get more money than trading it in.

Go for it man! :D
 
if you buy the taco you'll have to go over to tacomaworld, those guys are azzholes :hiding:

Those guys are awesome. Been loving it there! Maybe I just fit in. Lol

OP my wife just got a 2012 Tacoma Double Cab 4x4 sr5. We are loving it. I only drive mine now to work or if it's my only vehicle.

I would not have traded in my 4runner. Instead we saved a big down payment. Trade in not with it. If you can keep both I recommend it.
 
So it's a 1996 and you've had it for 8 years? I'd say you've had a good run. Time to upgrade. Go for the Tacoma and enjoy the additional HP and lower miles. I'm sure you'll love it. If you sell the 4Runner privately you'll almost always get more money than trading it in.

Go for it man! :D

I just checked my title and I was wrong. Bought it in Nov of 2008. So almost 9 years!
 
I own both my 98 4Runner, and my 05 Tacoma TRD Sport. I love them both... but my 4Runner will always be my favorite.

The Taco will be much smoother to drive, have more HP... and be "Newer".... the 4Runner can still be a great vehicle.

I've had mine for 13yrs now... I've changed out my suspension... did bushings, links... brakes... starter, timing belt, alternator... rear axle seals... I've done pretty much all of the work myself. They are easy to work on... reliable as hell... and if your's is in good condition with minimal to no rust... I'd just kee....... er... I mean... sell it.... sell it to me.... sell it to me now! ;)
 
if you buy the taco you'll have to go over to tacomaworld, those guys are azzholes :hiding:

lolololololololo. I know you're just giving him the business.

TW has a large group of enthusiasts that willing to help sort through choices just like T4R.org, so I think you'd be in good hands if you left.

Don't bother trading you 4runner though. Hold onto it if you can. It's paid for! Or sell it privately to get a fair price.

Those double cab Tacomas are NICE! But thru are expensive. Too much for me now. I will have to give it a few more years to get closer to not blowing up my single income bank account. LOL.

I would say get it, keep the 4runner for a while, or forever, and if you find yourself not liking one or the other, get rid of it. You can't lose money on the Taco.
 
lolololololololo. I know you're just giving him the business.

TW has a large group of enthusiasts that willing to help sort through choices just like T4R.org, so I think you'd be in good hands if you left.

Don't bother trading you 4runner though. Hold onto it if you can. It's paid for! Or sell it privately to get a fair price.

Those double cab Tacomas are NICE! But thru are expensive. Too much for me now. I will have to give it a few more years to get closer to not blowing up my single income bank account. LOL.

I would say get it, keep the 4runner for a while, or forever, and if you find yourself not liking one or the other, get rid of it. You can't lose money on the Taco.

Yeah the tacos are overpriced. $18500 for my wife's 2012 DCSB with 140k miles. Ridiculous.
 
Yeah the tacos are overpriced. $18500 for my wife's 2012 DCSB with 140k miles. Ridiculous.

Great Scott man!!

I guess I remember my 1994 being somewhat expensive at around $10,000 in 2001. It had just under a hundred thousand miles. But prices for good Toyota Seas days I've gotten out of control. I can't imagine spending close to $40,000 on a truck and then start to customize it by throwing more money at it. And then it would make me feel a little bit sick to take it off road and have branches start scratching it. With my 2002 I don't have to worry about that quite as much.
 
I would say get it, keep the 4runner for a while, or forever, and if you find yourself not liking one or the other, get rid of it. You can't lose money on the Taco.

If possible, I think this is the wise course.

I have a similarly beloved 02 and have done a bunch of maint (but know there will be more eventually). I have taco fever as well. Trying to convince my better half (who has permanent stolen "our" 2014 TE) that I should get taco and keep the 02.
 
On the Tacoma, you might consider an aftermarket warranty just in case you get the timing cover leak or bad head gasket that can be an issue for the 4.0 V6.
 
Great Scott man!!

I guess I remember my 1994 being somewhat expensive at around $10,000 in 2001. It had just under a hundred thousand miles. But prices for good Toyota Seas days I've gotten out of control. I can't imagine spending close to $40,000 on a truck and then start to customize it by throwing more money at it. And then it would make me feel a little bit sick to take it off road and have branches start scratching it. With my 2002 I don't have to worry about that quite as much.

Thats why we got the deal. Some scratches and miles. But one owner, 26 service records at the dealer in 5 years and accident free. Most 2012 non trd's still go for $25k these years. TRD's can fetch 30K+ still.
 
I paid $21,500 for my 05 Taco in 2012... it had about 99000 kms on it.... bad cigarette smell in the cab... but the body was near mint with just a couple of dings... undercarriage looked clean, and engine bay was super tidy.

The Taco's are fun... but prone to Frame rot... mine had it's complete frame replaced last year, under warranty of course. They replaced a slew of parts as well... the truck drives like new now.

I'm a Toyota nut though... if I had my way.. I'd have both my trucks... an old 70's Landcruiser, a 1st and 2nd Gen 4Runner.... etc.... lol!
 
Those guys are awesome. Been loving it there! Maybe I just fit in. Lol

OP my wife just got a 2012 Tacoma Double Cab 4x4 sr5. We are loving it. I only drive mine now to work or if it's my only vehicle.

I would not have traded in my 4runner. Instead we saved a big down payment. Trade in not with it. If you can keep both I recommend it.

[MENTION=122914]baja1[/MENTION] is right at some level. I've been interacting with people on Tacoma World in the 1st Gen section sharing the videos [MENTION=102606]infamousRNR[/MENTION] and I have been making and there is a definite difference between this forum and that forum. There are more a*shole comments and attitudes over there in Tacoma World but maybe I bring it out in some people. I don't know. By far, this forum has the best contributing people, bar none.

Now, if you want to be around a bunch of dickheads, go check out the 3rd Gen Mafia Facebook page. Somebody will ask a question looking for some help and at least 50% of the comments are just smartass BS. There's good people on there too but it has a huge population of immature idiots no doubt.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,316
Messages
3,554,120
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top