Great timing on this thread! I came on here today to do some research on this exact topic, and have been looking at the BF Goodrich Radial Long Trail T/A to replace my oem Michelins. I have 70k miles on the 4runner, and the Michelins are starting to show thier age. When doing my brake job last weekend, I noticed the rear tires are probably 1mm from the wearbars. The fronts are probably 1.5-2mm from the bars "haven't rotated in 10k miles". I really don't want to spend the money, as we're preparing to move to Chicago in two weeks, and spending a lot of cash right now to get the house ready and so forth. BUT, I also don't really feel comfortable driving all that way on those Michelins either. The Michelins are actually starting to rot on the inside part of the tire, along the rim. The rubber is spidering. And so is the spare tire underneath. So, I guess I've got to bite the bullet on this one, damnit. The car is originally from Illinois too, and I think the winters and road salt are what caused the spidering rubber. Since I'm not going to be driving the 4runner nearly as much after we move, I'm hesitant to spend the extra money on the Michelins, if they're just going to spider again in that kind of environment.
Michelins are about $210 per tire, but the BF's are in the $130's range. That's about a $300 +/- difference. So, borgzman, you really like your BF's? How do they handle in the heavy rains? Snow? Are they close to the Michelin's in terms of the quiet and smooth ride? Soft sidewall to absorb a lot of the bumps?
Thanks borgzman for you help!