BlairB said:
Any recommendations/ideas?
Well, you guys seem to like off-roading over rocky terrain from the pictures. Ask yourself this question: what is one of the pain-in-the-ass thing that can happen on an off-road trip that is easily preventable??
If you guys like rockcrawling or going over rock gardens, then a bad set of tires can truly debilitate your 4runner within an instant. A strong set of tires means that you don't have to worry about tire puncture while enjoying the scene and, quite frankly, give you more "balls" to do more stuff.
If you guys like mud or dirt roads, then yeah, get any tire you want. But, over rocks, you need a strong sidewall. Sooner or later, you will get burn.
If you want to stick to all-terrains, then you only have a few true choices: BFG AT KO, Goodyear SilentArmor, and other smaller production AT tires from dedicated off-road manufacturers (like ProComp, Cooper, etc.). For me, i would stick to BIG tire companies and with tires that have 3-ply sidewall and a proven history of toughness. That leaves me with two choices: BFG and Goodyear.
(Note: i have had Nittos TG, Michelin LTX M/S, REVOs, BFG AT KO, and Firestone Destination M/Ts...so, i speak from MY experiences.)
As for BFG's "poor" on-road performance, i don't care too much because #1 i don't drive fast in my 5500 lbs SUV, #2 they have never failed me before in years that i have had them either on-road or off-road, and #3 they are one of few TRUE all-terrain tires that lives up to it's name.
Question: did you buy your 4runner to go up against a Porsche Cayenne OR to go places where Porsche Cayenne can only dream of????
Just remember, i think that BFG AT KO is also the best selling all-terrain on the market by regular folks and by off-road enthusiasts. You can look at the bias TireRack consumer ratings all day long, but you need to pay attention to what tires people are actually buying with their hard-earned money....
Now, if you want to be more capable, then get Mud-Terrains. I did that a while back but the tradeoffs (noise, rough ride, poor wear & balance) was significant enough for me to jump back to all-terrains. By all means, mud-terrains are superior to all-terrains off-road by a long shot.
It all depends on your priorities.