Cardone Reman Brake Booster = GARBAGE

BamaDrewski

New member
So, rather than drop some $800+ on an OE brake booster back in October 2017, I purchased a "Cardone remanufactured" brake booster from a reputable parts site.

Just 16 months later, the POS has failed leaving me in the lurch. So, word of warning for anyone considered this brand (Cardone) of re-manufactured brake booster - DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY.

Searching parts yards now for an OE....
 
Register to hide this ad
With the exception of calipers, anything reman'd is taking a risk. I refuse to put reman'd parts on my 4Runner but I have plenty of junkyard parts in it. Sorry you had to learn that one the hard way.
 
Did you look on eBay for a used oem one ? Did you try local junk yards or car-parts.com ?

As mentioned in the original post, I am stalking pull yards for an OE booster. I sent Cardone an email but don't have high hopes they will respond. If they do - then great. If not - at least I can warn others......
 
Power booster

The Seiken brake booster P/N W0133-1741918 is supposedly the OEM. I replaced mine back in November with this booster and it was identical. It's a little expensive $340, but I wanted a quality part and this was the best one I could find short of getting the same part from the dealer for a lot more. U can get this on Amazon.
 
The Seiken brake booster P/N W0133-1741918 is supposedly the OEM. I replaced mine back in November with this booster and it was identical. It's a little expensive $340, but I wanted a quality part and this was the best one I could find short of getting the same part from the dealer for a lot more. U can get this on Amazon.

Great post! I looked it up. Appears to be a likely OEM supplier. Even if not, then this is a brand new Japanese made part. That info right there makes it a better bet. If it is OEM, then $340 is peanuts.
 
I should also add this booster worked for my 2000 SR5 4runner and I'm pretty sure this booster had the same p/n on it as my original one and indeed is made in Japan, which made me feel better about purchasing it.
 
Avoid CARDONE completely. I have used their reman parts for a long time, but in the last year their QC is crap. I bought powder coared calipers for my car an one leaked like it was pissing on my wheel. The replacement caliper shows wetness along the seamline of the two halves. Im too lazy to swap it out again.

Two years ago, the cardone caliper I bought came pre-seized.

Steer clear of CARDONE.
 
What on earth are you guys doing with these reman parts? Beating them with hammers?

No need too, Reman folks do it before we get the parts, Lol.
Like [MENTION=78997]Drcoffee[/MENTION] mentioned, I bought reman calipers whoever did the work didn't
torque bolts that hold halves together o-ring blew out first hard braking I did.
[MENTION=25434]BamaDrewski[/MENTION], Thanks for the heads up!
Look on the bright side, I have a 01 with the hiiigghhh dollar brake system.
 
I have a brand new reman booster and am suspicious that it is junk right out of the box. The seiken seems to be a great option and I am filled with regret for my reman booster.

Anyone know a way to test the actual amount of assist the booster is putting out?
 
I have a brand new reman booster and am suspicious that it is junk right out of the box. The seiken seems to be a great option and I am filled with regret for my reman booster.

Anyone know a way to test the actual amount of assist the booster is putting out?

Why do you speculate it is junk right out of the box?

Typically you need to actually install it to test the functionality of it. It operates off engine vacuum and I'm not sure if you'll damage something by actuating without a master cylinder on.
 
Why do you speculate it is junk right out of the box?

Typically you need to actually install it to test the functionality of it. It operates off engine vacuum and I'm not sure if you'll damage something by actuating without a master cylinder on.

It was installed by my mechanic as a replacement for the 21 year old factory unit that went bad. When I panic stop, aka slam the brakes, the pedal is absolutely rock hard at the top of the travel and the truck doesn't slow well at all. After it is held for what feels like an eternity (actually probably two seconds) and the pedal goes deeper into the stroke the truck does slow and it seems I have boost low in the travel of the pedal.

As the beginning of the stroke seems to be the issue, I thought this might have been an issue with the check valve that it was shipped with, so I bought a Toyota factory new check valve and grommet, but the Toyota one is way larger than the replacement valve. This actually leads me to believe that the booster which was put on the car is not a factory reman as the hole which accepts the check valve and grommet are not the same size as the Toyota factory version.

When I had the check valve which came on the reman booster off I blew some air into it to see how smooth it was and was not impressed. The Toyota version easily allows air to pass and promplty shuts when vacuum goes the wrong way. The one that came on the reman has a lot of resistance to airflow and the valve itself does not seem super compliant in shutting when, as Garth Algar may say, you go from suck to blow.

Is my line of thinking way off? O'Reilly sells a cheap plastic universal booster check valve I was considering installing to see if it helps at all.
 
It was installed by my mechanic as a replacement for the 21 year old factory unit that went bad. When I panic stop, aka slam the brakes, the pedal is absolutely rock hard at the top of the travel and the truck doesn't slow well at all. After it is held for what feels like an eternity (actually probably two seconds) and the pedal goes deeper into the stroke the truck does slow and it seems I have boost low in the travel of the pedal.

As the beginning of the stroke seems to be the issue, I thought this might have been an issue with the check valve that it was shipped with, so I bought a Toyota factory new check valve and grommet, but the Toyota one is way larger than the replacement valve. This actually leads me to believe that the booster which was put on the car is not a factory reman as the hole which accepts the check valve and grommet are not the same size as the Toyota factory version.

When I had the check valve which came on the reman booster off I blew some air into it to see how smooth it was and was not impressed. The Toyota version easily allows air to pass and promplty shuts when vacuum goes the wrong way. The one that came on the reman has a lot of resistance to airflow and the valve itself does not seem super compliant in shutting when, as Garth Algar may say, you go from suck to blow.

Is my line of thinking way off? O'Reilly sells a cheap plastic universal booster check valve I was considering installing to see if it helps at all.

How does it perform under normal braking? I'm inclined to believe that a functioning brake booster is going to work or not. I do suppose it is possible that it isn't getting enough vacuum to function properly when panic stopping. Do you know that your master cylinder is working correctly?

If the check valve isn't fitting it probably isn't a factory reman. At least that is what a factory part not fitting would imply to me.
 
It was installed by my mechanic as a replacement for the 21 year old factory unit that went bad. When I panic stop, aka slam the brakes, the pedal is absolutely rock hard at the top of the travel and the truck doesn't slow well at all. After it is held for what feels like an eternity (actually probably two seconds) and the pedal goes deeper into the stroke the truck does slow and it seems I have boost low in the travel of the pedal.

As the beginning of the stroke seems to be the issue, I thought this might have been an issue with the check valve that it was shipped with, so I bought a Toyota factory new check valve and grommet, but the Toyota one is way larger than the replacement valve. This actually leads me to believe that the booster which was put on the car is not a factory reman as the hole which accepts the check valve and grommet are not the same size as the Toyota factory version.

When I had the check valve which came on the reman booster off I blew some air into it to see how smooth it was and was not impressed. The Toyota version easily allows air to pass and promplty shuts when vacuum goes the wrong way. The one that came on the reman has a lot of resistance to airflow and the valve itself does not seem super compliant in shutting when, as Garth Algar may say, you go from suck to blow.

Is my line of thinking way off? O'Reilly sells a cheap plastic universal booster check valve I was considering installing to see if it helps at all.

sounds like my problem. new brake booster it is. i just replaced my check valve and grommet and it doesnt make a difference.
 
How does it perform under normal braking? I'm inclined to believe that a functioning brake booster is going to work or not. I do suppose it is possible that it isn't getting enough vacuum to function properly when panic stopping. Do you know that your master cylinder is working correctly?

If the check valve isn't fitting it probably isn't a factory reman. At least that is what a factory part not fitting would imply to me.

Normal braking is underwhelming at the moment. If I slam them eventually theres a point where the fronts grab in a big way and stop the car with great prejudice, but normal braking is unimpressive and theres that pesky hard brake pedal at the top of the stroke when i slam the brakes.

I just talked to my mechanic and am going to bring it by to have him drive it. He said the brakes were even "super touchy" when the truck left the shop. Will update with results.
 
Normal braking is underwhelming at the moment. If I slam them eventually theres a point where the fronts grab in a big way and stop the car with great prejudice, but normal braking is unimpressive and theres that pesky hard brake pedal at the top of the stroke when i slam the brakes.

I just talked to my mechanic and am going to bring it by to have him drive it. He said the brakes were even "super touchy" when the truck left the shop. Will update with results.

Under normal braking conditions does the pedal function as normal? A brake booster should generally just work or not. There really isn't much too them. A non-properly functioning master cylinder can cause all sorts of issues.

Great video of a breakdown of the inner workings of a master cylinder and brake booster: YouTube

I'm interested to see what the outcome is as well.
 
My 4runner is doing the same thing. Installed used OEM booster and same issue. When I panick stop I have no assist.

This is extremely vague. Did you have the issue before swapping to another OEM booster? I'm under the assumption you did since you swapped parts. Throwing grenades at problems isn't the way to go.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,310
Messages
3,554,080
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top