Jetboy
New member
FWIW - a 5th gen out of the box has a lot of advantages over a 3rd gen. The significant increase in strength of the front drive system and the traction control systems give it a big leg up in performance in stock form.
As I'm sure you know, the 3rd gen is a great base vehicle but needs a handful of upgrades to get serious about the harder offroad trials. Namely it needs at a minimum a set of locking diffs and typically also a front end upgrade. The 7.5 isn't known for being particularly strong, nor are the front axles. It generally also needs one of the various solutions to upgrade the upper ball joints. Otherwise it's a very good platform to start with. But it's really not as capable off the shelf as a 5th gen. As a result over time unless your 3rd gen is double locked and has fairly large tires, you'll find that the 5th gen is typically enough better that you'll be using it more and more.
That said - I really loved my 3rd gen and have considered buying another one to build a dedicated family trail rig out of. I think the 3rd gen and the LC80 are the two best platforms to start with for a family crawler given how cheap they are and how much you get relative to the starting price. I see a lot of really cheap 3rd gens around that are a fantastic starting point. IMO the best build for me for an all around family crawler is something like a 3rd gen on about 40's with a LC 9.5 rear axle or an 8.2 and a 30 spline reverse 8" front IFS conversion (basically swapping 5th gen running gear). The Front Range 4R is fantastic as an all around crawler/family hauler. So I don't think there's any reason not to consider keeping both if you're going to build the 3rd gen into a more hardcore crawler. OTOH if you're only planning on a 3" lift and 33" tires - the 5th gen will end up being what you use for everything I'd bet.
As I'm sure you know, the 3rd gen is a great base vehicle but needs a handful of upgrades to get serious about the harder offroad trials. Namely it needs at a minimum a set of locking diffs and typically also a front end upgrade. The 7.5 isn't known for being particularly strong, nor are the front axles. It generally also needs one of the various solutions to upgrade the upper ball joints. Otherwise it's a very good platform to start with. But it's really not as capable off the shelf as a 5th gen. As a result over time unless your 3rd gen is double locked and has fairly large tires, you'll find that the 5th gen is typically enough better that you'll be using it more and more.
That said - I really loved my 3rd gen and have considered buying another one to build a dedicated family trail rig out of. I think the 3rd gen and the LC80 are the two best platforms to start with for a family crawler given how cheap they are and how much you get relative to the starting price. I see a lot of really cheap 3rd gens around that are a fantastic starting point. IMO the best build for me for an all around family crawler is something like a 3rd gen on about 40's with a LC 9.5 rear axle or an 8.2 and a 30 spline reverse 8" front IFS conversion (basically swapping 5th gen running gear). The Front Range 4R is fantastic as an all around crawler/family hauler. So I don't think there's any reason not to consider keeping both if you're going to build the 3rd gen into a more hardcore crawler. OTOH if you're only planning on a 3" lift and 33" tires - the 5th gen will end up being what you use for everything I'd bet.