Just went into my local America's Tire store.
First one basically argued with me about how these are discontinued or used tires. Left there.
Went to the one I normally shop at. They explained that eBay kicks in $50 and Discount Tire kicks in the other $50, so what they could do is match the price before discount, plus $50 (To match DTC portion) for every $400.
After doing the math, I was able to get E Load tires at the 6 ply price (Guy didn't realize the ones on eBay were 6 ply) minus the $50. They are Nitto Trail Grapplers.
Nitto then has a Rebate visa card of $70, when you buy 4, plus using my CareCare1 card I get $30 added to the $70. So in all, I was about $180 (had to pay tax) more than the online eBay price, but they are E Load rather than the 6 ply on eBay. Not too bad, plus I keep my relationship with the local guys going.