Somehow this became about what tire was best, not what gets better MPG AT or MT.
I get it, you like using a tire that has not changed in 35 years, you give a big middle finger to the massive advances in tire technology.
To answer the OP about what tire is best for him, we would need to know his driving conditions, and intended use.
You BFG guys really really love your over the hill tires, and I struck a chord with you and messed up this guys thread, I'm sorry. Please forgive me and let's move on.
You're right mate.
So I'm in Australia, I'm driving mostly on paved road and beaches.
Every couple of weeks I go to the Bush for some 4x4.
I'm using mud tires at the moment and thinking about improved Fuel consumption.
Thanks guys