Girlfriend needs a new car..suggestions?

FWIW, Consumer Reports just released their latest vehicle quality rankings...
1> Subaru
2> Mazda
3> Toyota
4> Honda

I've had two Subarus, my wife currently drives a 2001 Subaru Forester and I'm hoping that she'll upgrade to a new Forester this year. Subarus are great cars for the money... very reliable, safe, AWD, decent mileage, and all three that I've had have had heated seats!


Not exactly dude. Those "overall" rankings don't tell the while story. The Toyota Camry was named best family sedan Again.

Consumer Reports put out its annual car ratings this week and not surprisingly Japanese brands scored the best, just as they have for a generation of automaking.

Consumer Reports releases annual car ratings - latimes.com
 
Last edited:
Sounds like you took that as a personal attack Brian. I think the link you posted said exactly what the guy said. 1)Subaru 2)Mazda 3)Toyota 4)Honda. He wasn't misleading anyone. Just stating the facts and giving his personal opinion. Besides the name of this thread isn't what is the best family sedan, it's a dude getting ideas about what car to help his girlfriend look for.
 
Sorry, I didn't mean to sound like a jerk. I was just in shock that Mazda was rated higher than Toyota and wanted to state that a Mazda 3 is not a better car than say a Prius or Camry .

Btw, I saw the movie Chronicle last night, very good movie.
 
Get a Subaru. I've got an '05 Impreza 5-spd and have had no troubles. Good gas mileage, great in the snow, and feels like a go-cart compared to the 4runner!
 
The wife drives an '05 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited wagon, it's been a great car! AWD, heated leather, a HUGE sunroof, lots of room. My only regret is we didn't go for a GT, more power, extra gear in the auto, LSD rear diff, and similar fuel economy.

That being said, Honda makes great cars, and Toyota makes great (although bland) cars as well.
 
I believe a Honda CRV to be a great vehicle for a woman. Dead-bang reliable, good visibility, very practical, 4WD on most, reasonable mpg - not exactly beautiful. Wife's on her second one and I bought my daughter one.

They hold value too.

My wife drives an '09 CR-V. My 19 yo daughter drives an '05 CR-V which I paid 10K for with 46K miles. My 16 yo son drives an '07 Impreza which I paid 10K for. I drive a Toyota. I go for reliability and durability. Can you see a trend here?
 
subaru or a toyota.

not that big of a honda fan or nissan for that matter.

probably would lease myself a hyundai before i went for a honda or nissan.
 
I believe a Honda CRV to be a great vehicle for a woman. Dead-bang reliable, good visibility, very practical, 4WD on most, reasonable mpg - not exactly beautiful. Wife's on her second one and I bought my daughter one.

They hold value too.

I'm going to second this, one of my old girlfriends drove a CRV, she got great mileage. Also, she crashed it three separate times - and with each crash she and the car came out fine. I never drove it, but it's definitely a reliable ride.
 
The Focus is such a piece of junk...

We have a lot of focuses at our dealership's Enterprise Rent a Car... they all constantly have problems. My favorite is that on every single one of them, the headlight brackets break for no apparent reason.

Well, the no reason other than it being a Ford...

Is that a graded bolt? Does it say 8.8 on the head? To hold down a piece of plastic?
 
My parents have two 4th gen camries, a 1998 which I drove from 2007 until 2010 until I got my runner, and a 2000 which they bought for my sister in 2008, both 4 bangers. Both were purchased with around 100k and now have around 135k on each of them and they run flawlessly. No drivetrain maintenance besides oil changes and two tranny flushes has been done to each within that period of miles. Sometimes it's a relief to jump in the old 98 camry and just drive. The tranny is tight and the engine still purrs. It's so much more easy to drive then my 4runner. My sister's car is even in good mechanical shape despite that it's a girl driving the sh1t out of it and bascially neglecting it. Just my 2 cents....
 
My parents have two 4th gen camries, a 1998 which I drove from 2007 until 2010 until I got my runner, and a 2000 which they bought for my sister in 2008, both 4 bangers. Both were purchased with around 100k and now have around 135k on each of them and they run flawlessly. No drivetrain maintenance besides oil changes and two tranny flushes has been done to each within that period of miles. Sometimes it's a relief to jump in the old 98 camry and just drive. The tranny is tight and the engine still purrs. It's so much more easy to drive then my 4runner. My sister's car is even in good mechanical shape despite that it's a girl driving the sh1t out of it and bascially neglecting it. Just my 2 cents....

had an 05 camry 4 banger LE and i gotta say its alot easier to drive on long hauls.
 
My wife drives an '09 CR-V. My 19 yo daughter drives an '05 CR-V which I paid 10K for with 46K miles. My 16 yo son drives an '07 Impreza which I paid 10K for. I drive a Toyota. I go for reliability and durability. Can you see a trend here?

Sure hate to have your car insurance bill.

:eek:

This was a screaming deal! "'...05 CR-V which I paid 10K for with 46K miles..."
 
Not exactly dude. Those "overall" rankings don't tell the while story. The Toyota Camry was named best family sedan Again.

Consumer Reports releases annual car ratings - latimes.com

Sorry, I should have said "reliability" rankings... I was half-listening to the local news. And yes, they are "overall" ratings, but at least reliability seems to be a better indicator than initial quality. I always like to see resale value trends. Excluding regional market conditions, you can get a pretty good idea of the reputation of a vehicle or brand... again, subjective, but another tool to help make a buying decision.

"In this year’s rankings, four automakers – Subaru, Mazda, Toyota and Honda – were judged by the magazine to have “very good” reliability. The nine remaining companies all had “good” reliability. Not a single automaker had the lowest ratings of “fair” or “poor” reliability."
 
Thanks for the help guys, i really appreciate it. My girlfriends loves her moms CRV but does not want a vehicle of that size at the moment! Thanks again!
 
I know there older but what do you all think about the Toyota Echo? I know someone who has one and he loves it. Edmunds consumer reviews are great also.
 
I vote for a Subaru (Forester, Impreza) or a Corolla/Civic. I go for reliabilty and crash test ratings...I have a Forester as my DD.
 
Don't buy a cheap Ford, that's a disaster waiting to happen. Highly recommend a Mazda 3 for a low cost, highly reliable, high quality car. Not sure how low mileage you can get for 11k, but it'd be worth a strong look.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,316
Messages
3,554,111
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top