I'd never sell my 4R, I love it too much, it is my dream vehicle.
For the sake of discussion, if there were no 4R's, I would have either a 1.5 or 2nd gen double cab long bed Tacoma... I like both gens a lot, but I think I would like to get a newer Tacoma.
Either gen is triple awesome with an ARB.
And yes, I'd stay Toyota.