I'm getting a new phone in a couple weeks. I would like to see this thread continue. I use my phone for making calls, text messaging, and taking pics and video of my 20 month old. I currently have a samsung captivate. I am not that interested in the numbers and technical details of an android phone or an iphone. I just want something that will take a good picture and a decent video. Also the phone should be able to stand up to the abuse of a 20 month old.
Million dollar questions. I will try to answer them. From the other thread, you seem to be stuck b/w iPhone 5 and Galaxy S3.
For me, the ONLY reasons that you should get GS3 are:
1. You like big screen, and/or
2. You like Android software.
GS3 is a very good phone. It is Samsung best phone to date. It has a nice processor and very vivid (oversaturated, but some prefer this) screen technology. But, it suffers from typical Samsung flaws including horrible cell radio (poor cell reception, esp if you're on CDMA networks), cheap-feeling plastic construction (i say feeling because supposedly, it is made from "good" plastics), and horrible after-sale service. Software updates take forever to come...just ask Koz!
Within Android nowadays, you have better options than GS3...all depending on what carrier you're with. GS3 will likely be replaced with GS4 early next year...so, why are you buying it now? What are the competition?
1. HTC DNA...it's just on Verizon. This is the latest phone from HTC with the latest hardware on any Android phone. It has a super huge 1080p screen (5")...bigger and better quality screen than GS3. Its processor (S4 PRO) is the latest from Qualcomm and is quad-core...again, much better than GS3 (in USA). The materials are of much higher quality (and design) than GS3. Downfall? Battery life may be bad if you use it a lot (big arse ultra-high resolution screen + quad core CPU ain't good for any battery!). In addition, although HTC has a long history of great customer service, it is on rapid decline from a market share point of view and thus is financially limited. Why do you care? Well, this may affect future software updates and future development of the phone. What is HTC top dog now? I thought that it was HTC X One (as HTC claimed when it was introduced)...but now you have DNA...i am very confused! And this is bad for future product support!
2. Google Nexus 4 (from LG)...this is if you're on GSM network. With GSM, i highly recommend Straight-Talk. There is no point in signing contract with ATT or T-Mo when you have Straight Talk!! Straight Talk is no-contract cheap plan that uses ATT network (including HSPA+). However, no LTE...a downfall, but not too bad since you still have HSPA+. Nexus 4 has a big screen...about same size as GS3, but MUCH better quality (more accurate colors, etc.). HTC DNA still better though. Nexus 4 also has the same super quad core processor from Qualcomm (S4 PRO) as in HTC DNA. And since it is pure Google phone, it will be updated in a timely manner for the next 2 years...much better than Samsung and HTC. Downfall? Well, camera is not as good as HTC nor GS3. It is very heat-sensitive which results in dethrottling of processor (bad for games!). The glass panels break easily, as was the case with iPhone 4/4S. So, you need a case/bumper for sure!
Now for the iPhone 5. iPhone 5 is probably one of the toughest phone that you can buy in terms of handling drops. It will scratch easily, but your phone will function. (see:
http://www.toyota-4runner.org/1200289-post58.html) No contest b/w GS3 and iPhone 5 in the toughness argument.
iPhone 5 has the best camera and video combo. It has arguably the best camera, beating the low-light expert (Nokia 920), HTC, and GS3. Video is excellent as well. Although it does suffer from flaring at times, this is the case with ALL phone cameras (and most P&S cameras). Examples of flaring in other cameras?
1. GS3:
http://www.toyota-4runner.org/1197972-post42.html
2. Nokia 920:
http://www.toyota-4runner.org/1236506-post153.html
3. Nexus 4:
http://www.toyota-4runner.org/1223647-post114.html
As for screen display, iPhone 5 may not have the highest resolution, but it sure has the best quality display on the planet. (see:
http://www.toyota-4runner.org/1196493-post9.html) In addition, pixel density has gone wild in newer phones...with questionable benefits and one horrible side effect (battery life!):
Tech's New Most Meaningless Spec: PPI
As for processor, the Apple A6 (dual core, customized designed by Apple) is a powerhouse! It has the best combination of CPU and GPU processing...by a very wide margin in some cases. And it is super power efficient...easily beating out all Android not named RAZR Maxx HD. These qualities put it well above the latest Qualcomm chip S4 PRO despite it being a dual core CPU & triple core GPU. This can clearly be seen in the 1st page of this thread.
Specs are useless when it comes to smartphones. Optimization of software and hardware is what makes or breaks a phone...it is what separates the top phone from the bottom. Just ask Windows phone...the previous gen Windows phone had only one core CPU but it was able to beat most Androids with dual cores via software optimization. This is simply where Apple excels because it controls both software and hardware. No Android can claim this. (And this is why Windows also has very specific guidelines on their phones hardware.)
Lastly, of course, there are iTunes and App Store that are second to none. The Apple ecosystem is superior...but, i must admit that Android is pretty nice too (minus all the viral apps). Apple is simply a more secure system if privacy is important to you. And yeah, with any phone + 20 months old, you need a case!!
Hope that this is helpful.