Need Opinions.. Keep Runner or take Tacoma.

Moroney167

New member
Ok. Long story short. I have has trucks since my first vehicle. F150. 3 F250's, a Excursion 7.3. Was a diesel nut. Don't tow much at all anymore. Got a work plow truck so that helps. Loved the hell out of my 5 Jeeps (1 XJ 2YJ's and 2 TJ's.) listened to now wife and got a 97 4Runner. Fell in love don't know what I was missing. Grew up in my moms SUVS (2 Jeep XJ's a Grand Cherokee and Lincoln Navigator which I took my driver test in.) let's say I love everything. Change what I drive a lot. And I LOVE my new Runner. I'm one month away from a year owned and at 18,300 miles. Wife has had many toyotas. Loves Tacoma. Had all Generations. Loves the new ones. I hated. It has grown on me. She at the moment has a 2015 Tacoma TRD sport access cab which I did up nice. Let's say I like it as much as anything else I have. Has 21,000 miles.

She wants. And as anyone with a wife knows, she will I'm sure end up getting the new 2017 model. Would be a 2017 TRD sport again all white. Misses full 4 door as main issue. Probably get a 4 door long bed. I'll re level the front end and keep simple with her favorite wheels red off what she has now. She loves sunroof and would love the creature comforts. Mine has them, I just want AC and not roll up windows haha. Although I like being spoiled. I drove my rusty jeeps anywhere everywhere highways u name it weather and all.

Option A we trade in her Tacoma, get the new and I keep my runner.

Option B we trade in my Runner which is worth much more money on trade. We are both well ahead of our payments. She owes 6k maybe. I owe maybe 20k on Runner. If we trade my Runner in I take her Tacoma.

I do love it. Much less cool features which I really never use. We do not have or plan on kids. Have 2 dogs. I ride my bikes to work mainly or drive which isn't far. I deff could use a truck more more than SUV. Only time using all seats is rare little times, but I'm the control freak who always drives groups or not. I mountain bike a ton so ride 3+ times a week normally. Even winter if not bad. Ride dirt bikes, transport bikes also. Low bed height I do love on it. Occasional towing both would do fine, Tacoma does feel more solid longer WB and leaf springs rear. 90% what I do. Tacoma would work fine and I do love it. Never use my heated seats. Never have more than us 2 anyway. When I do long highway trips we used runner but, her truck well just take now. If I kept Tacoma I would consider a cap to keep somewhat classy and not have to clean back like I do runner... Or just a roll up cover to keep dry and use hitch more.

Sorry Kong post. Brains smoking on better option. Tacoma I have setup with 5100's all stock. .85" front so it's level. I would throw my 17's and BFG's on it with hopes they fit and probably look awesome. Trading in whatever as close to stock as I can. Her Tacoma also has TRD exhaust and filter because why not!

Any suggestions opinions or Insite?
 
Register to hide this ad
I personally hate the new engine and trans in the taco. I'm a little biased but if it were my money I would keep both, pay them off and then buy a dedicated fun rig whatever that is for you. To give you a little background I went in to my local dealer to buy a taco and left with a t4r because I couldn't stand the new drive train.
 
I've driven several new Tacomas, I currently own a 13 trd off road. Sorry to say the new taco is not a upgrade. I was waiting for the new taco to trade. I drove one and decided to get a new 4runner. The engine is underpowered the trans is busy and quality is currently lacking in fit and finnish. If you really like the tacoma don't get rid of your four 4runner for one you'll be sorry.

Sent from my VS985 4G using Tapatalk
 
I personally hate the new engine and trans in the taco. I'm a little biased but if it were my money I would keep both, pay them off and then buy a dedicated fun rig whatever that is for you. To give you a little background I went in to my local dealer to buy a taco and left with a t4r because I couldn't stand the new drive train.

Appreciate the input. I do agree I'm not to wild on new Tacoma. But to clearify that would be the wife's new truck. Which is just a driver daily for her and has room for the dogs, friends whatever. Truck bed she does enjoy having. She did have many Tacoma prior. 1 4Runner 4th gen and she still just loves tacomas. She would not notice a thing for what she owns. If I took her 2015 Tacoma that would be my DD. If we did a long trip, probably use her 4 door for room inside to keep bags and all dry. If we ever camp, we'll probably tow a soon to own pop up/very small camper. That's a maybe.

I've driven several new Tacomas, I currently own a 13 trd off road. Sorry to say the new taco is not a upgrade. I was waiting for the new taco to trade. I drove one and decided to get a new 4runner. The engine is underpowered the trans is busy and quality is currently lacking in fit and finnish. If you really like the tacoma don't get rid of your four 4runner for one you'll be sorry.

Sent from my VS985 4G using Tapatalk

Again thanks for all Input. Of course my daily routines and possible needs will be different than others so nothing always applies 100%. Main thing for new taco is that it is a little more quite on road. Has sunroof she misses. Heated seats basic stuff like my runner has. Trust me I tried having us switch she does t like my runner much at all like a Tacoma! Sucks would make life easier. I do love my runner. Feels solid. Would take a lot of convincing to give it up although I love the 15 Tacoma, my runner just does it all. I like things enclosed and locked sometimes. Also with a few hitch attachments and having a nice small enclosed trailer it can do just about whatever.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    139.1 KB · Views: 824
1) Kick her ass to the curb
2) Buy yourself a 5 year old 4Runner that you pay cash for and invest every penny you can NOT IN TRADING CARS IN EVERY 1.5 YEARS
3) And 5 years from now you can settle down with a nice Jersey girl who doesn't mind a 10 year old minivan. ;-)

I'm serious.
 
Sounds like your wife is a BMW girl trapped in a taco. Lol jk. Seriously trading in cars like you are doing is crazy. I could understand trading it in for a larger truck if you needed the extra capacity but just trading in for a 2017 taco is stupid. And even considering trading in the t4r for a taco is beyond comprehension, good luck. You might be better off building a pile of cash in your driveway a lighting it on fire.
 
I know I've mentioned this in other threads, but I can't begin to express how happy I am to be back in a 5th gen 4runner after owning a 2016 tacoma. I didn't have any problems with the motor, but I did have issues with the manual transmission sticking in-gear after long periods on the freeway. Look it up on tacoma-world there's plenty of info. I'm sure toyota will take care of the issue, but it was the final nail in the coffin for me.
 
Resentment aint just a river in Egypt...


if you trade in that 4Rnnr for her, and in a yr or two start NOT liking what you got in trade, you WILL regret it.

It sounds like you guys are financially straight, just let her do whatever it is she feels works for her, because it sounds like you have already done so for yourself. She wants a new Taco, she can have one...because if/when the 4Rnnr gets changed to being whatever the next one will be, you will be glad you kept it.

IMHO

...now if i could just get my wife to trade in her almost useless convertable Seabring (which she loves dearly) and get her to buy her OWN 4rnnr Premium, leather-sunroof-running boards-etc...and STOP wanting to drive mine :boom:
 
Appreciate the input from ones with the new Tacoma. By no means jumping into this. And still need to test drive one. By noooooo means is she a BMW girl, but thanks for trying I guess? We love the truck now she has just had many instances where she needed 4 seats when it was not an option to just go home and could just grab my runner.


Been in touch with friend who is a tech at Toyota and boy what the hell did Toyota do with this new truck. I know there are happy customers out there but the 4.0 sure never got anything like what you hear now
 
1) Kick her ass to the curb
2) Buy yourself a 5 year old 4Runner that you pay cash for and invest every penny you can NOT IN TRADING CARS IN EVERY 1.5 YEARS
3) And 5 years from now you can settle down with a nice Jersey girl who doesn't mind a 10 year old minivan. ;-)

I'm serious.

Thanks for the constructive life advise. Perhaps I depicted my wife wrong? I had a 97 Runner. Loved missed sure. Love my new runner to much. Never going to own a minivan sorry. Never will be with a jersey girl. And. It's life, I can afford it, so if we have had issues and times she has needed that extra space than we have justified to bite bullet on it. This forum is riddled with people who I question how they trade cars in every year sometimes. I have owned every vehicle outright until these two. Which I pay off ASAP. We may not do it at all, being research and his many people are saying the new truck is a flop

Givin needing another truck sure isn't over needed when I have a F350 work truck to use for heavy towing. And maybe forgot I just don't give a %#+=.
 
I'm in the process of trading a loaded 2016 Tacoma TRD Sport (double cab, 7k miles) for a 2016 4Runner Limited. Hoping the Limited arrives Saturday.

I thought the Taco was sharp and fun to drive, but just didn't make as much sense as I thought it would. The interior volume was severely lacking, the seating dynamics were exceptionally poor, and the bed was too small to be that useful.

In hindsight if I ever went with a truck again I'd only consider full size.
 
I'm in the process of trading a loaded 2016 Tacoma TRD Sport (double cab, 7k miles) for a 2016 4Runner Limited. Hoping the Limited arrives Saturday.

I thought the Taco was sharp and fun to drive, but just didn't make as much sense as I thought it would. The interior volume was severely lacking, the seating dynamics were exceptionally poor, and the bed was too small to be that useful.

In hindsight if I ever went with a truck again I'd only consider full size.

Thanks I agree with most of that. It's a tuff call. Again. My new Runner sure is awesome.

I was stoked for the new taco..... then I drove it.... kept my 4runner

More I read in Tacoma forums it's 50/50. She loves her truck now and seems like I'll talk her into keeping and ignore new Tacoma until who knows when something maybe more worth it comes along. After sleeping on it I'm pretty sure I'll be nuts to downgrade myself. My runner is just awesome to drive, and I put some miles on it. It's towed better than I expected when needed.

Slim chance though I pick up another full size truck though, really don't feel like working on diesels anymore! (FORD that is haha)
 
I have traded in my vehicle so my wife can get something new a couple of times. We would do it because my vehicles were worth more as a trade both times. I always felt like a great husband, but in the end, I missed what I had. My wife would also get bummed and feel guilty because she knew I loved what I was driving.

My advice, keep your 4runner and pay off the Tacoma. That will give her a little time to figure out what she wants and you will have a paid for trade when the time comes.

I love my 4runner and will not part with it for at least a decade, amazing vehicles.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,313
Messages
3,554,090
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top