Well I have been crunching numbers. On the surface it seems like $100 off is a lot, but it's working out different than I expected, all things considered.
I've been working to build a relationship with my local tire shop and now that they are getting to know me, I've been getting really good treatment there. So there is that to keep in mind.
I called and got their quote and broke it down. Given I still have to pay for mounting and balancing, and they give me a free alignment with a set of tires I don't get bringing my own (and I always get with new tires), if I can still get the $70 mail in rebate from Cooper it came down to a grand difference of:
+$36.88
I'm not sure I got tax included in there right, but basing it off the final OTD price with just the tires pulled out to compare against this deal, I think it's pretty accurate.
Plus I get free rotations from them if I get tires there. So what, I can do that myself right, but I can't balance them myself.....so then it starts to be nice to be able to drop by and have them rotate and balance them for no charge when I need it. If I don't buy from them I don't get that.
So, is it such a great deal if we are only talking $40 more vs. a Mom and Pop shop, knowing them if I say the $30 or so is hanging me up they would knock that off.