What should I do?

Need more demographics from you.

You single?, married?, kids?, dog?, sports-ethusiast?...

The Bimmer is one sweet ride at $39K and so is an older T4R, although in need of repair. What type of vehicle is going to be the most practical for your life's pursuits and experience? If you are single and want the 'business-type'... "Hey, I've got money!"-look,... then keep the BMW. If you are any of the latter, I'd probably hold on to the T4R.

IMHO, and 'if' you are a family man, I would sell both and get another T4R that is a bit newer but still used, say...an 07-09. There are a ton like this out there that go for >$20K with 45-60K miles. The T4R is bigger, probably safer, and more roomy with stow space than the BMW is. Bank the money. Most millionaires drive old, beat up pickup trucks anyway! :banana:

single with gf...no pets anymore. love sports. lol
 
If you are single and want the 'business-type'... "Hey, I've got money!"-look,... then keep the BMW. If you are any of the latter, I'd probably hold on to the T4R.

Funny cuz those cars a actually less expensive than a comparably equipped Runner limited. I laugh at peeps that go and buy used POS Beemers and drive them around like they are "ballin." Not directed to the OP btw...
 
Keep the BMW, so long as your not getting a ton of speeding tickets, it's more fun to drive, and its a manual, should be cheaper to use yearly anyway...
 
I've had BMW's, and Toyota trucks and SUV's. In comparing the two marques; The BMW's were great to drive, when something wasn't malfunctioning on them. The Toyota's were all dead reliable.

I still have a '97 4Runner that I bought new, that has had mostly just regular maintenance. The only things I've repaired in 14+ years of owning it are:
Starter Solenoid contacts
O2 Sensors (just in the last month)
Clutch hydraulic hose
Replaced headlight bulbs a few times, a couple taillight bulbs

That's it.

I never imagined when I bought the '97, that I'd still own it 14+ years later. But it's reliable and drives like the day I bought it. I can't bring myself to get rid of it, even if it is mostly just a winter driving vehicle these days.

I used to work as a Master Tech, and found back in the day that Toyota's were far more reliable than European or American cars. I have friends that work on all brands of cars currently, and they tell me that in their experience, that still applies today.

I personally wouldn't own any late model BMW out of warranty.

Good luck with your decision.
 
Funny cuz those cars a actually less expensive than a comparably equipped Runner limited. I laugh at peeps that go and buy used POS Beemers and drive them around like they are "ballin." Not directed to the OP btw...

I think that's like comparing apples to oranges, both vehicles do completely different things. I'm personally considering 'consolidating' because although I have a great job, i want to bring down my debt and cut expenses as much as I can right now. It's tough because cars that drive like the bimmer (awd or rwd with all the fixing, great braking/handling) seem to be less reliable.
I was looking at an fx35...but they are just as crappy on fuel as the t4r.
 
Keept them bouth and then buy a yellow 95 Volvo and we can be twins.

Seriously I would just keep them. I got almost 100k on my BMW and the 4Runner just turned 100K on the way to work this morning. Volvo turned 200K last week. I plan to keep all three of them for a while and maintain them the best I can doing whatever I can do myself. I figure the 4Runner is good for well over 200K, but not sure about the BMW. I like taking turns driving the different cars because they feel so different from each other.
 
I don't understand the obsession with having a "new" car. Payments on whatever new car you buy will likely be less than the out of pocket cost of maintaining either of the rigs you have.

Personally, I'd sell the car and put the cash into maintenance and upgrades on the Runner. But then, I drive a gen1. :D
 
I think that's like comparing apples to oranges, both vehicles do completely different things. I'm personally considering 'consolidating' because although I have a great job, i want to bring down my debt and cut expenses as much as I can right now. It's tough because cars that drive like the bimmer (awd or rwd with all the fixing, great braking/handling) seem to be less reliable.
I was looking at an fx35...but they are just as crappy on fuel as the t4r.

+1 on comparing apples to oranges.

I would probably keep the Bimmer - more fun from a performance and handling standpoint. However, since you spent a good chunk of change on the 4Runner, I'd say keep both! haha
 
I don't understand the obsession with having a "new" car. Payments on whatever new car you buy will likely be less than the out of pocket cost of maintaining either of the rigs you have.

Personally, I'd sell the car and put the cash into maintenance and upgrades on the Runner. But then, I drive a gen1. :D

i should have rephrased...not brand new, but new enough so it has low miles and warranty still (1-2 yr old) something
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,309
Messages
3,554,075
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top