Why did you pick the T4R over the FJ or Wrangler Unlimited?

Beating a dead horse

WARNING: This review IS just beating a dead horse. There is a wealth of experiences and good knowledge on here but because I have had a Grand Cherokee, Wrangler and most recently a 4runner, I felt like throwing my experience into the ring (and in part to selfishly meet my post minimum).

My previous two cars were a 2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee (Limited with hemi) and a heavily modded 2011 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited (35 inch tires, 3.5 inch fox/teraflex lift, interior roll bars, 5 point harnesses, bumpers, winch, etc.).

To start, my Jeep Wrangler Unlimited was probably the most fun car I have owned prior to my 4runner. It is what got me into offroading, wrenching on my own car and generally being in the outdoors more. That being said though...like others have said, the interior is very sparse. And for how much you pay for one, you'd expect a little bit more. It was a very analog truck with everything being so easy to take apart and I definitely get the draw for that. But you don't drive one of those for the comfort factor. Then my steering issues started. I blew a power steering pump and that usually wouldn't pose the biggest issue, but after it was replaced, I had chronic steering issues. My power steering pump would randomly go out so the steering wheel would go from light to super heavy to light at random moments. I had it replaced FOUR times. Then they replaced the entire steering column after it kept happening. The last problem with it is how horribly under powered it is. I did have 35s and I did not regear so that's my own problem but still, it was incredibly sluggish to where if I had one or two other people in the car, the power was noticeably different.

Then I had the Jeep Grand Cherokee. I live 2 blocks from my office and the only driving this thing ever saw was fairly easy highway miles. Before I started having any issues with the car I had a litany of safety recalls. It was some ridiculous number and even for things as stupid as the headliner occasionally can catch fire. Outside of this, random issues occurred. The power lift gate which you can't really operate without it using the motor, started malfunctioning. The button wouldn't get it to close and usually just didn't work on cold mornings. So I'd have to force this thing closed against the motor power. Then the shift timing on the 8-speed transmission would slowly become out of sync and would downshift at weird times, not downshift at all while flooring it (at extremely low RPMs), and generally be a pain. I had to have them re-set the electronics that managed this transmission 3 separate times. Then came the U-connect. Don't get me wrong, this was probably the most user friendly system there is and the backup camera was incredible. But randomly dropping calls, the system shutting off while I was driving, and the navigation input randomly taking up to 15 minutes to load was insane. Long story long, this car had an enormous amount of problems.

Finally after being very disenchanted with the Jeep brand and being frustrated with reliability issues, I made the switch over to the 4runner. I don't need to tell anybody here because we all know how great they are but it is just such a great balance between luxury and offroad capability. AND you have the ability to modify these extensively having the great aftermarket that it does. I only have an SR5P but have taken it to Moab and living in Denver and I am beyond impressed with it in it's stock form. Not that it'll stay stock for long (especially perusing this forum) but it is the best daily driver/weekend warrior combo I have ever owned. The v6 although not the most powerful, has a ton of top end torque. Despite what most people seem to think here, I really like the Entune system. It has the interior space of a full sized, while not being obnoxiously large. It is a great all around, do-everything SUV and the reliability is unparalleled.

I'll end my rant there but there is nothing that compares to the reliability and build quality (except for the cheap plastic in these haha) of Toyotas and the 4runner.
 
I had 2 FJ's. Went to 4Runner only because of growing family of 5! Needed more room, and 3rd row seat. I still dearly miss my FJ's, but 4runner is 2nd best. imo....

Mike
 
Not sure about that depreciation part. The Wranglers, 4runners and Tacomas are in a very unique situation where they somehow defy the depreciation norm of nearly all automobiles. Of course there is still some off the top, but once a wrangler hits a few years old, they seem to stay steady for quite a while. I came from a '12 Rubicon, and an '11 Rubicon (both 2dr, 6-speed), both lost nearly no $$ over the time I owned them (nearly 2 years, 31k miles for the 12, 1 year, 12k miles for the 11).



You are mostly right, but I'm driving 40k miles per year. The 12 Rubi would have over 150k on it by now. That would make a dent on its value had I kept it. Now I have a 4R for half the price of what I got selling the Wrangler. I can drive it without worrying what it's worth in relation to what I paid.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Howd i miss this thread...:confused:

Quicklist... im sure. I wont get everything and wont touch "cons" for now

Here's where they are similar
-Great resale value
-Off road capable
-Pricing
-Strong ownership following

Jeep pros
-Convertible option
-More aftermarket support
-Domestic (not a pro for some)
-Can remove the doors
-Arguably easier to mod, especially suspension

4Runner pros
-Sunroof option
-power rear window
-Reliability (not that JKs are unreliable, 4Rs are just more reliable imo)
-Cargo space/optional 3rd row
-More optional creature comforts

I've really enjoyed both vehicles. I had quite a bit of fun in the Jeep but am looking forward to another 4R.
 
Couldn't decide which one to get so between the wife and I, we have all 3. '12 FJ cruiser, '13 JKUR, '15 TRD Pro 4runner. And I've kept my '94 wrangler since highschool - still able to be a decent daily driver with a/c, new carpet, and able to maintain 70mph on the interstate.
 
I just recently bought my 2016 TE, coming from a multi car environment I wanted something that could generally do it all. I had a 2013 Mustang GT that was my baby finishing up college and has treated me really well (despite being an idiot magnet and getting bumped into once a year) and fornutility I've been through two jeep Cherokees in the 95-01 timeline.

So far neither beat the comfort, peace of mind, and "it just works" factor. With the jeep every time I put the key in I had to cross my fingers something new wouldn't pop up. And the mustang I drove only occasionally because I babied it too much.

Starting a family in the next year or so, I wanted space too. And something my fiancé and I could adventure in. She has a 99 4Runner and loves it, and can't wait to get her 5th gen! I've just heard for years that Toyota makes a quality car that holds value and I finally stepped up to get one.

That's the last point for me. The mustang was in near perfect condition, with great mods that to me enhanced the value of the car. But Susie and Jane can go buy a 2016 V6 vert freshman year and trash it and that's the image people get of mustangs now a days. So he stang was bleeding value at a crazy rate. 4runners seem to always beat depreciation.
 
Older thread, but still an intriguing question.

The FJ Cruiser is no more, so wasn't an option.

Not asked, but I had a 2005 Nissan Xterra, and would have likely purchased another, but those are no longer offered. I put almost 100K on it before trading it. It was a really capable 4x4 SUV.

The older Pathfinder was a very good vehicle. The current version looks like a minivan. Fugly. I don't need a 3 row seat, or monitors in a headrest. Pfft.

As for a Wrangler, I had a 2004, and traded it off. Later bought a 2006 Wrangler Unlimited (long wheelbase version). It was the last year for the inline 4.0L 6 cylinder. We still have it. It's been my wife's daily driver for the past 11 years. Lots of fun off-road, and surprisingly comfortable on long road trips. Got almost 100K on it, not getting rid of it. But we will modify it more, and when we buy a motorhome once again, it will be towed behind.

12096246_10208492650979757_4366486552197828853_n.jpg


jeeptoberfest.jpg


My daily driver is a 2010 F150 FX4 Super Crew Cab. Great for hauling a golf cart in the bed while towing our travel trailer. It parks like a city bus, but not a problem for me. It's got the last of the 5.4L V8s. I had no interest in the turbo V6 in the 2011 models.

2.jpg


And finally the wife's new daily driver. It will be our first choice of vehicles on vacations that don't involve the camper. We are both approaching retirement, and wanted a VERY capable vehicle to travel anywhere in the country, any time of year. The 4Runner fits that bill.

img_7867-001.jpg


So it's not a matter of one or the other for me, but rather which suits my needs for the day. Having options is great! A man can never have too many toyz...
 
I never considered a Jeep. Drove an FJ. Love they way they look from outside, hated the interior and driving it. Loved my 3rd gen 4Runner. Love the facelift 5th gen, it was an easy call.
 
I loved my jeeps (XJ, TJ and JKU (pictures attached)). But now im more into overlanding/expedition so I decided to go with the 4Runner. I have always watched and read about Toyotas in Australia and Africa, 4Runners, Land cruisers etc... They are very reliable and strong. Now I have a family, its more comfortable form them, we have more space and is just an amazing 4x4.
 

Attachments

  • DSCN0620.jpg
    DSCN0620.jpg
    88.8 KB · Views: 509
  • DSCN0611.jpg
    DSCN0611.jpg
    100.4 KB · Views: 527
  • River_Crossing.jpg
    River_Crossing.jpg
    41.8 KB · Views: 524
Really wanted a Jeep for the cool factor. Easy to lift, big tires, top off. But knew in reality it wasn't going to be as nice as a new 4runner and it didn't have the towing capacity for me. Plus I have always owned Toyota products 2-Tacoma 3-4Runners counting my 2015 and I know that Toyota reliability is unbeatable
 
Last edited:
Quick answers:
  • Jeeps are for girls.
  • FJ was not for sale any longer. - FJ was my first choice.
  • T4R is a great all around SUV. It has comfort, space, good engine, etc.
  • Dodge Ram - im not into dodge.
  • Range Rover - looked too wimpy for the price

I'm gonna get $hit for saying this.... but here it goes.

If you want to overland, go with T4R. If you want to get into rock crawling, get a jeep rubicon or a used FJ.

From my past experience, Jeeps/FJ rock crawl much better than a T4R. T4R is very capable, and is great on the rocks, but its like riding a limousine over the rocks, while the smaller/shorter/lighter jeep & FJ hop over the rocks with ease.

When I was rock crawling in my T4R, i parked it and jumped in a friends Rubicon to see how that drove over the rocks, and really, it was like jumping on a dirt bike. Smaller, lighter, faster...i just like the way it handled the rocks.

Other than rock crawling, jeeps are terrible. Bad MPG, not reliable, no comfort, and the list goes on, etc.
 
For me it was a matter of what happened last. I had my last (2001) 4runner for 16 years with very few problems. It served me well and took me every place I wanted to go. Before that, my 1987 (purchased in '86) lasted me 15 years with very few problems.

Given that kind of history, upgrading from an 01 to a 2017 was a total no-brainer. I looked no further than purchasing another.
 
I knew that the nuances of the Jeep (reliability concerns aside) would get to me after a while.

The 4Runner is pretty damn quiet, comfortable, roomy, full of relatively nice tech, and came in equipped as I wanted cheaper than the equipped as wanted JKU.

I would be full of shit if I don't still have the Jeep itch. I loved my XJ, and LOVE the ease (and price) to modify a Jeep. The shear amount of parts are incredible. And, damn are they easy to make real big and real capable. Plus, lets be honest, they just look damn cool when modded. Oh, and the color options are downright awesome.

I also knew that due to my time of purchase living situations, and still current working situations (park in an off site lot, in the heart of downtown), I wouldn't be able to comfortably take the hardtop/hard doors off often, and I'd definitely not enjoy (or want) a soft top. That said, I do like the angled back soft tops a LOT!

For me, and what I feel many else in this thread, it came down to realistic needs over simple wants.
 
I really wanted a JKU, but just couldn't make it happen. 4R wins hands down with comfort and reliability. It fits more, hauls more, tows more and has less quality control issues than the Jeep. ...but that JKU is still drop dead sexy to look at.
 
just went from JKUS to T4R

just went from JKUS to T4R about 5 months ago.
the main reasons for switching was the reliability and everyday comfort and functionality of the 4Runner is just superior the the Jeep. i'll probably get another Jeep someday but only as a second vehicle.
 
I didn't. I have a 2012 4 dr. JK Rubicon on 37's. Also now a 2012 T4R SR5. I travel in the 4 runner through wherever, and play in the Jeep.

First post. HI ALL!
 
Wrangler? Nah...

Tried to talk the wife into an FJ, but she wasn't keen on the doors for hauling kids. As far as a Wrangler, never been a fan. I do like Chryslers from 1965-1972 though.
 
Back to Toyota

Old thread, but still very valid today.
I’ve owned 8 Toyota’s since 1992. In 2005, I bought a New Jeep Liberty KJ. OME kit, but stock otherwise. Loved it and planned on buying an Unlimited next.
With only 7,500 miles per year, regular service and care, the Liberty was great until 100k. 2 water pumps, split radiator, alternator, starter... and at 120k a blown head gasket on the 3.7. I got 15 years out of it, but was disappointed after such careful maintenance since new.
I swiftly dumped it and now back in the Toyota family. Plan on driving this for 15 years and giving it to my son.
 
We're another family that has both a 2017 JKU Rubi and now the T4R SR5. While different, they are both great and we'll be keeping them for a long time. Also for fun we have a '96 4x4 4-door Tracker that is manual everything and blast to take off-road. Good to have choices.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,315
Messages
3,554,130
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top