I just this fall traded in my 2010 4Runner for a 2020. I bought the 2010 new, and it lived all 10 years in central New York. I did not have it undercoated or rust-proofed when new. I was at 155,000 miles when I traded it in. Overall, it still was in good shape, but with the 2020 updates I decides to upgrade, instead of waiting a few more years for a 6th gen.
Overall, it survived well, but this year is started to show it's age:
Body - over held up well, no rust, other than the tailgate. it started rusting from the inside out, and I was getting rusty water running out the drain holes after car washes. I had to replace the tailgate latching mechanism once due to corrosion. It still looked good from the outside, but I knew that wouldn't last much longer.
Underside - Frame was fine other than surface rust. The skid plate under the engine rotted out to swiss cheese and I had it replaced last year. The exhaust heat shields (mounted to the body, and to the headers/pipes/cats) all fell off in the past couple years. I started going through a lot of siezed brake calipers towards the end (avoid the aftermarket ones). The tow hitch was covered in rust but structurally fine. I had issues with the neutral safety switch on the transmission but it was frozen to the shaft and I could not get it off to replace it (oddly enough, after trying to get it off it worked fine 95% of the time until I traded it in).
In the winter I park in an un-heated garage at my home, and it sits outside when at work. I have a monthly automatic car wash subscription (delta sonic) which I use at least every 2 weeks or so in winter.
For my 2020, I had it undercoated and rustproofed when new. But, overall, after 10 years my 2010 held up pretty well with the upstate NY climate. Much better than my wife's Honda, which started rusting pretty bad about 5-6 years in.
I live in Western NY so I know me some rust.
Wondering if these are known for being good for rust, or bad, all things considered?
A friend told me he just checked out a used 2017 and it was pretty bad underneath, not completely destroyed but it definitely looked like more than just a little surface rust.
If I'm looking at 2015-2016 models up here is this something I really need to check out? Thanks!