While the Scosche kit looks more like stock, I prefer the clean lines (and area to mount switches) of the Metra kit. The bevel around the screen on the Scosche probably works fine for units where the screen is only the size of the double DIN, but I think it would just look weird with an 8+" screen there.
For those who've had both, did Scosche or Metra fit into place and stay without rattle better or was it just a cosmetic decision? No many places carry the Metra kit (not even Crutchfield), so I might have to special order it if I want it.
Also instead of having the trim painted to match the other panels has anyone tried some 3M vinyl wrap instead? I was thinking the brushed aluminum to see how well it matches the trim piece above the glove box. Would love to see pictures if you have it!
I was definitely in the "clean lines of Metra" camp until I saw it in person. The plainness of it makes it stand out as a "this has been modified" feature. I thought I'd hate the Scosche kit, but the audio shop insisted that it would look better than the Metra after it was painted to match the interior and I think they were right.
I tried 3M vinyl wrap and it delaminates if the interior gets too hot. Audio shop said they have that issue with it a lot, so they shy away from using it.