I went with the Airaid tube. I was doing the ISR mod when I noticed a healthy tear in the stock rubber intake tube. I checked around at junk yards without any luck and being Arizona and how dusty it is here I just went with the Airaid. I like it a lot. Clean, easy install. I put that with a K&N in the stock air box (someday I will put on a snorkel). I noticed better power on the highway but that's really it. Nothing to go crazy about. It is also really loud when you have to get into the throttle.
My last car I gained 10 HP redoing the intake and exhaust. I know because I put it on a dyno. So I figured what the hell and started to do the same with the 4Runner.