I got them yesterday. My one of my only complaints is that I didn't get the white lettering on the sidewall, which is Americas Tire/Discount Tire's fault for not sending the correct tires. My second complaint is very important for you northerners: the three peak snow flake rating that is required by some local governments for winter tires is not present of the 265/70R16 tires, YOU HAVE TO GET AN LT TIRE WHICH IS AVAILABLE ONLY IN 265/75R16 SIZE. I wish I got the snow rated ones, but that would add an extra inch of height and a lot of weight for the upsized tire.
I bought my 4runner with Cooper Discover ATPs that were scavenged by the previous owner from a tire shop (they were the same size as the new tires). The Goodyears handle better, they ride better, they give much less road noise especially on the highway than my Coopers did. Nothing against the Cooper ATPs, they did a valiant job considering they came off another vehicle and were 7 years old. The Coopers are also much more off road oriented so this isn't much of a surprise.
This is on dry pavement, a budget tire from 40 years ago could do the same thing. The real test will be in the winter on wet roads, or maybe even snow. So take this with a grain of salt.
Jury is still out of fuel consumption. I just filled up but that wasn't a clean slate for the new tires, I have the calculations from over a year of driving in a variety of conditions and will know immediately how these new tires affect my fuel economy.