OEM rubber mats are great!
I had them for about 4 mo now and I'm very happy with them.
It's a bit strange in the begining, because it's got a "sticky (tacky) feel" to it. I was used to a certain feel when my feet were resting on the oem carpet mats. Don't get me wrong, it's not a bad feeling, but a little weird in the begining.
It also has high ridge patterns on the mats so it traps a lot of the junk that you bring in from the outside.
I've had Weather Techs in the past, and they are very good, but they cost more. Huskys... Many members swear by them, so they must be good.
The only bad thing about the stock mats... The rear mats are two piece and they don't cover the center hump like the other brands do, which is a minus, because the edge of the hump always get soiled first. I think the Weather Techs and Huskys' rear mats are one piece and cover the center hump.
btw, if you decide to go with the Weather Techs, know this. The original weather techs (classic) are ok, not good. The new model (Floor liner) is what you want to get. I'm sure, that the Weather Tech model discussed in these forums are the "FloorLiner" model, which are in this "deep cavity" category.