We are talking the exact truck, same year, same color, both have new tires, moon roof, unused towing, previous one owner with complete Toyota service records showing oil changes every 5K. The only difference is leather seats, premium stereo, and 96K less miles which are a lot of miles. I opted to spend a grand more in service because I want to start fresh knowing everything is in order. Thats just me being me.... so for 10,000, I am happy with my purchase and it runs nice and tight. That being said.... Would I prefer to pay 17K for yours or 10K for mine? Personally, I would rather pay 10K and save the extra 7K. However, I am not saying that 17K is a bad deal. You have already determined that by looking at NADA and KBB. It looks to be a nice truck with extremely low miles and if you say there are none around your area and this will make you HAPPY then go for it! I would stick to my guns at 17K for the same reasons as stated by Mike in NH. Make sure u check the actuator (black box next to transfer case) for leaks, stuck calipers, cracked manifold, and any suspension noises (sway bar bushings were needed in mine). Make sure you ask him what it needs and what problems that he had to have fixed. Bring it to a mechanic and have him go through it and put it on a lift if possible. Good luck, let us know how u made out/