I went with the Kenwood XR but honestly if I had to do it again I would have gone with the cheap amazon sub instead, you're really not going to get much out of an 8" in that enclosure.
I also used the lazy hot knife cut instead of removing the whole side panel and its been holding up fine for last 4 years, you cant even tell it was cut out.
I went with a Rockford Fosgate P3SD2-8 when mine blew. I have no complaints what so ever about it. Great little sub with good lows, mids and highs for just the right price.
Very easy/lazy method, just take a knife, heat it up, cut out the surround. I used a folding husky box cutter knife with a fresh blade.
With a clean cut the mesh surround just pops right back in. A few forum threads detail the process.
Downside is you lose protection for the sub from objects being thrown around in the cargo area but I keep a ton of crap back there and never had an issue. Also easy access in case sub goes out again in the future.
I bought a Pioneer TS-2000LD2. I understand why it's a popular sub but it just doesn't do the job for me. I'll replace that one a little while down the line
What did you not like? Did it sound like the stock woofer, which I have never heard. I'm not looking for a competition sub. I just want the rear channel to sound normal-ish, whatever that is.
I never heard my stock sub because it was blown when I bought the car. Don't get me wrong, it's a good sub, but it is not what I was specifically looking for (because i'm an audiophile lol). I listen to rap music, and this sub doesn't play the low bass very good. Everything else it's perfectly fine.
I don't think any rap fan rocks an 8 inch sub. I went to a stereo installation shop to see if they had something off the shelf and they laughed at me. Anyways, based on your other words, I think the Pio will be fine.
What are you hoping for with the replacement? Are you going to replace the factory amp too?
When my sub blew, I decided to redo the entire system. I went with a Fosgate
T1 10inch. Running off of a Fosgate T1000x5. Made my own enclosure for it and I cannot believe how much better this sounds. I was totally impressed that it performs the way it does.
Been in there 2 years now, working great.
![]()
More images in the link in my sig of the system as I was putting it together.