O2 vs. A/F sensor question

2DaMtns

New member
If I put an "O2 sensor" instead of an "A/F mixture sensor" on a 2000 Limited with California emissions, would it still cause it to throw the P0171 code? I had a couple shops scan mine and they all said it was the O2 sensor. Replaced it, no help. Talked to a dealer, said most independent shops don't know that the CA models actually need an A/F, not an O2. Any truth to this, or is the dealer trying to get my money?
 
Register to hide this ad
listen to the dealer, and try and return the O2 sensor (maybe clean it up first) i just replaced my A/F sensor last month, 250ish (for the part) at my local dealer.
 
2DaMtns said:
If I put an "O2 sensor" instead of an "A/F mixture sensor" on a 2000 Limited with California emissions, would it still cause it to throw the P0171 code? I had a couple shops scan mine and they all said it was the O2 sensor. Replaced it, no help. Talked to a dealer, said most independent shops don't know that the CA models actually need an A/F, not an O2. Any truth to this, or is the dealer trying to get my money?
\

I don't even think that an 02 sensor would plug into the A/F harness plug. And yes, a 2000 cali emissions (2 cats) would most likley have an A/F sensor. They are two completley different and non-compatible sensors that cannot be interchanged. Just contact the dealers parts department, give them your VIN and confirm that you indeed need an A/F sensor.
 
Well, the part I put on mated up to the wiring harness, and what I ordered was called an 02 sensor for Cali model, so should I assume that it is the right part since it fit the harness? Sorry to keep at this, but I hate to throw a couple hundred bucks at this unless it seems like the right part.
 
2DaMtns said:
Well, the part I put on mated up to the wiring harness, and what I ordered was called an 02 sensor for Cali model, so should I assume that it is the right part since it fit the harness? Sorry to keep at this, but I hate to throw a couple hundred bucks at this unless it seems like the right part.

I hear ya. There are a few other potential causes for a p0171 (bank one too lean) code. I can be caused by a dirty MAF sensor (most common), or a vacuum leak letting air in after your MAF sensor. Take a look at this thread:

http://www.yotatech.com/f2/maf-cleaned-before-after-pics-2000-4runner-119266/

Should get you started on how to do it. It is very easy, just be careful with the sensor once you get it out..
 
An O2 sensor for say a 2000 V6 Auto with federal emissions will not fit a 2000 V6 Auto with Cali emissions, the harnesses will not match up. Trust me on that :bash:
 
Thanks for the replies guys. I have tried cleaning the MAF sensor, but the dang screws holding it in stripped out. I took the entire breather tube off and used a liberal amount of MAF cleaner. I got it to look much better visually, but I still intend to get the sensor itself out and clean it more thoroughly before I go blowing more $$$. Other things I have tried include changing ECT sensor, airfilter, TPS, and cleaning the throttle body. It runs a heck of a lot better but it still has the code and still cuts out at about 3/4 throttle and beyond. As for what part I actually put on this thing, I have no idea...??? Like I said, it was listed as an O2 sensor and not an A/F, but it's listed as California emissions on the decal under the hood, but not the sticker on the door (That one says federal). The car has a clean carfax, but I guess someone could have put a new hood on it themselves. But anyway, when I get an answer, I'll post it up. And thanks again for all the replies.
 
check under your truck, if you have two cats you have a cali emmisions, if you have one, you are federal
 
and greedy is correct, i geuss i was just tired, but a p0171 code is a dirty MAF most of the time... so pull it out and when you put it back in, replace the screws with a similar bolt and you wont strip them ever again
 
I got two cats, so it's Cali. There is an upstream and downstream sensor, and there is a plate welded over a hole between the cats. Do the Cali models usually have a 'midstream' sensor? What is this 3rd hole for?
 
RunnerUp said:
listen to the dealer, and try and return the O2 sensor (maybe clean it up first) i just replaced my A/F sensor last month, 250ish (for the part) at my local dealer.

250'ish:jaw drop: I got mine from Toyota Offroad Parts for 156 or so.
 
hossmaster said:
250'ish:jaw drop: I got mine from Toyota Offroad Parts for 156 or so.

what, you couldnt have told me this like two months ago???

haha, damn i wish i knew that then!
 
UPDATE - SOLVED!!!

So I finally just bit the bullet and took it in to the dealer. Told me the MAF sensor was shot. I had already tried cleaning it, and while I could not get at it all that well cause the screws stripped out and I was too lazy to get them out, I have to wonder if it truly was shot since my honest attempt at cleaning didn't improve a thing. So, I had them replace it. Maybe I got screwed a little, but the freaking thing is running properly now, so I'm OK with it. The cost including diagnostic hookup, parts, and labor was right at $230, so I don't think they gouged me too bad either. Anyway, thought you'd all like to know what the final diagnosis was.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,307
Messages
3,554,054
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top