Outdoor Grill Shopping - Recommendations

Mytoy4

New member
I want to get my husband a nice grill for fathers day. Anyone have any recommendations? I have researched some, but get a lot of mixed reviews.
My budget is in the range of $300-$500.
 
Register to hide this ad
I got a really nice 4-burner at sears for around $400. Also get one stainless steel or without paint. My sisters burned off all the paint within a couple years and looked like hell. also make sure the grates are heavy cast iron and not stamped metal which will warp. Good luck!
 
He definitely needs this:
 

Attachments

  • grills_for_real_men_8sfw.jpg
    grills_for_real_men_8sfw.jpg
    40.2 KB · Views: 288
More realistically though, Quatre is right. Either stainless steel, or enamel finish. I personally like Brinkman, and you can get some seriously impressive grills for $2-300. Home depot usually will have the best selection, and always seem to have a sale going on.

One cool option to consider is, some grills are made for natural gas, which means instead of a propane tank, you just buy a special hose that connects to your house, if you happen to heat with natural gas. No worries about running out of propane.

Personally, I think this grill is a great choice.

Also, if you could find one fully assembled somewhere, he would definitely appreciate that. Assembling grills is a PITA
 
I've always wanted a Big Green Egg. There are some more affordable versions now too at Lowes/HD.

What does he grill? Is he a gas, charcoal, or wood guy?
 
I've always wanted a Big Green Egg. There are some more affordable versions now too at Lowes/HD.

My parents had one when I was in high school years ago- we loved that thing. Found it used. I think they are still like $700+ new though.

They ended up selling it for $300. OP, if you can find one used.. very worth it.
 
My parents had one when I was in high school years ago- we loved that thing. Found it used. I think they are still like $700+ new though.

They ended up selling it for $300. OP, if you can find one used.. very worth it.

Here's the one Lowes is selling now and it's about $300. I've checked it out a few times and it was hard to walk away. I just don't do that much grilling anymore.

Shop Char-Griller Akorn Kamado Kooker at Lowes.com
 
Look on CL. You can find great deals, and they're already assembled. A lot of the $300ish grills Lowes and Home Depot sell are not the highest quality. I've known a few people who got them and they only lasted a couple years. The pans will rust out and the grates don't seem to last that long. I found a Weber that was in great condition, just dirty, for $50!
Make sure you get a cover if it stays outside.

Weber makes one of the best grills, and they last a long time...Plus replacement parts are generally easy to find. Lowes has a good stock for Weber grills.

Weber Spirit E-310 3-Burner Propane Gas Grill-46510001 at The Home Depot

I've got the Spirit 310, and love it. It heats up fast (600* in about 7 minutes), and everything has cooked evenly. All Webers have their burners going left to right instead of front to back like a lot of other makers. I found it easier to cook indirectly that way.



Made some killer ribs Memorial Day...



 
Last edited:
Yes Webers are the best! They're just so darn $$$! I have a portable Weber charcoal grill that Ive owned for 30 years! Still in great condition. That Weber u 'stole' for $50 is sweet...
 
I've always wanted a Big Green Egg. There are some more affordable versions now too at Lowes/HD.

What does he grill? Is he a gas, charcoal, or wood guy?

Interesting type of grill. We use gas. Wood in the smoker. We grill everything, but he's the more creative one with it.
Fruits, veggies, various meats, bread... ect..
 
Last edited:
Interesting type of grill. We use gas. Wood in the smoker. We grill everything, but he's the more creative one with it.
Fruits, veggies, various meats, bread... ect..

I like the BGE because it has really good efficiency for a non-gas grill. It uses very little charcoal/wood/etc and has a big surface area like the old Weber round grills. Plus you can stack layers if you are smoking. And if you don't use all of the charcoal/wood you can stuff it out and use the rest later. I'm sure there's a lot more too it that can be found online, I just know I want it. :hungry:

My neighbor bought one a few years ago and I've checked it out on occasion. It seems like a big expense but I've been through two gas grills and two charcoal grills since then. I guess that $700 doesn't seem like such a bad deal in retrospect. The cheaper one I linked makes it even more tempting.

It appears that these are only charcoal, is that correct? You're right, such good reviews. Is it because of this shape?

Yeah, charcoal or natural wood charcoal. I think it's the shape, thermal properties/efficiency, and multiple uses that wins people over. Plus by itself it has a smaller footprint than some of these bigger gas units. My neighbor has his mounted on the rolling cart thing though so it's big... and awesome.
 
That's very tempting for sure. I just don't know how he'd feel about it. He really wanted a gas line ran to the house and had it done about 2 years ago. That's my only setback with this one.
 
That's very tempting for sure. I just don't know how he'd feel about it. He really wanted a gas line ran to the house and had it done about 2 years ago. That's my only setback with this one.

Yeah he'd probably prefer gas then. Some guys are very picky and specific when it comes to grilling. If you want it to be a complete surprise and not discuss it with him beforehand, I probably wouldn't give him a charcoal grill and see if the guys here can suggest a good gas grill.
 
Yeah he'd probably prefer gas then. Some guys are very picky and specific when it comes to grilling. If you want it to be a complete surprise and not discuss it with him beforehand, I probably wouldn't give him a charcoal grill and see if the guys here can suggest a good gas grill.

Yeah, I'd like it to be a surprise. I'm just kind of at a loss. I found 3 of them at Lowe's. Thoughts???
Lowe's: Shopping Cart
 
Yeah, I'd like it to be a surprise. I'm just kind of at a loss. I found 3 of them at Lowe's. Thoughts???
Lowe's: Shopping Cart

Shopping carts won't link. But I'd look for something with push button starters for all heating elements, porcelain coated grates, and something that fits his needs size wise. Weber really is one of the best brands but they are pricey.

The run of the mill stainless Char-broil/Master Forge types are the ones I kept having to replace. They look great out of the box and will work for a few years, they just don't seem to be meant for long term ownership, unless he is meticulous with care and stores it out of the elements.

Check reviews on Amazon too - they typically have more info than the store reviews.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,312
Messages
3,554,083
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top