I picked a new hatch button cover on Amazon: New IMPROVED GRIP Replacement Repair KITS for Lexus Toyota Scion Liftgate Trunk Hatch Back Door Handle Switch Release Opening Button Cover
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071DVJ6ZD?ref=yo_pop_ma_swf
Installed it today. Pretty easy jog—just be patient with removing/installing the screws as to not strip the Phillips head screws. Here are a few pics:
New button cover with angled screw driver:
Remove both screws then pry the button out of the slot; it’s clipped in with plastic body clips as you can see a couple pics below:
Now the fun part: peel and scrape off the old button. Wear gloves! What a sticky, nasty mess the OEM deteriorating button makes. Here’s the old button in a pile:
Oh, and notice the black washers above! I re-used from the original button; had to peel them from the old rubber.
Cleaned up the button as much as I could so the new button cover would go on clean:
When putting on the new button cover, it goes on just one way—you’ll see a more beveled edge on one side of the button and lines up with one side of the silicon cover; just look carefully and you’ll see what I mean. Here she is all nice and new!
Just snap the unit back into place, use washers noted above and secure with the screws. Took me about 20 minutes all said and done—would have been 5 min of it weren’t for the mess in cleaning the button.
-Dan