Excuse my ignorance, as I'm just entering the market for a 4Runner.
If 4lo has failed, what is the tell tale sign? Switching to 4lo and the vehicle will not move? Or does one look for a switch to light up on the dashboard?
I test drove a 2008 4R SE with 85k miles a few days ago at an indy dealership; I tried shifting from 4hi to 2hi, then I tried shifting to 4lo. He basically scared me and prohibited me from driving the car in 4lo, saying it would damage the transmission unless I was on driving on mud or snow or rocks. I was able to turn the dial into 4lo, but didn't put the vehicle in motion in 4lo. Otherwise I drove it in 4hi the entire time.
I went home and did a background check on Toyota.com, and sure enough 1 month ago prior owner brought the 4R into a dealership with complaint of the vehicle not engaging 4lo. Estimated repair costs was ~$3k which the prior owner declined. So I suspect this 2008 4R had a failing transfer case actuator, which this dealership knew and failed to disclose.
A few days later I test drove a 2011 4R Limited CPO with 67k miles; dial was on H4L, I tried shifting to L4L in neutral, and heard a mild "clunk." I suppose this was normal since the 4WD system light flashed on and off. I then tried dialing to H4F, where the dashboard's 4WD light remained on, so I wasn't able to drive it in H4F... I was only able to drive it in H4L where the truck got ~8mpg! This Toyota salesman didn't know what H4F was....
Did both vehicles have failing transfer case actuators? Thoughts appreciated, thanks!