We tested an extensive list of vehicles before going with the T4R. In fact, at first the 4Runner wasn't even on the list for us at first. We were looking for a family oriented vehicle that my wife can drive in poor weather and we can take on camping/road trips. We were not looking for an off-road monster.
So, we looked at
Rav4
- We were happy with it, but felt too much body roll around corners. We liked the mpg and V6 engine as well as 3500lb towing. What killed it was the packages. We wanted something nicer than the base model and less expensive than the Limited, but the Sport model came with RFT (run flat tires) which we didn't like, along with other small things we didn't like
Highlander
- On paper, looks like a good vehicle. This was one of the shortest test drives because we didn't like the interior layout of the feel of the drive at all.
Edge
We took a chance and test drove the edge, but felt like the price tag was set for all the (pointless) knick knacks inside, not the ride quality of vehicle, engine or longevity.
* Now that I have my new work truck (2011 V8 F150) I am sooooo glad we didn't buy a Ford with our own money because I would have been very upset with the outcome
Volvo XC 60
This was one of the closest runner up because of all the safety features, but every little add on cost an arm and a leg and we just didn't want to pay $40K+ for a vehicle that wasn't "perfect in every way" and only got driven on the weekends
Subaru Outback 3.6R
We loved almost everything about this car, except for the new generation had unresolved issues with shaking steering wheel/column. Even after multiple call backs, Subaru still couldn't get the problem fixed on a couple owner's vehicles and they had to lemon law those cars. We weren't paying $35K for a car with a 50/50 chance of that type of problem.
Finally, one day we decided to take a 4Runner out on a test drive, just because we had some time to kill before meeting family for dinner and fell in love. At that point, we decided to scour the web for the right 4th Gen T4R for us. We finally found it at Pappas Toyota in St. Charles. Which, by the way, was a great dealership to deal with. If we knew we were looking for this size vehicle from the get go, I would have also taken one of the new Explorers out on a test drive, but I already mentioned my feelings about Ford above.