We got both. We have an '07 Xterra and an '07 4runner SR5. The 4runner was about $4000 more, got it for 26500. I love the 4runner, would not get an Xterra. My husband loves his Xterra, would only buy a 4runner if there was no Xterra or the 4runner was diesel. Both have over 22K, none of them had any problem. The 4runner has much better ride. Both great off-road, or on the snow. About the same with gas. Also had an '06 Tacoma Xrunner, (the only way it comes is with 6spd manual, rear wheel, extended cab). It sucked in wintertime (with the stock 18" performance tires) and I got tired that my husband took my previous '04 4runner to get around in the snow. SUV is better for most of the time. Easier to carry stuff, more room for the dog, bike, skis or just to go to shopping.