Why do threads get closed in the 5th gen section?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think that the problem with "Newbs" not searching and starting threads that have been done before is that the search function in Tapatalk stinks. If I'm using this forum through that app and I search, the relevant threads never show up. If I search straight in Google (as 1E detailed in his sticky), I can usually find everything I need.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I think that the problem with "Newbs" not searching and starting threads that have been done before is that the search function in Tapatalk stinks. If I'm using this forum through that app and I search, the relevant threads never show up. If I search straight in Google (as 1E detailed in his sticky), I can usually find everything I need.

See, that's one of the biggest issues. A lot of folks don't use the google machine. On every single new thread that I have seen pop up, I go to Google, type in: 5th Gen T4r, (subject/question). 95-98% of the time, I find at least two or more threads on the subject (I also usually scroll through the thread to make sure there is pertinent info in there before pasting it into my response). The other 3-5% of the time I get back to the thread in question, and someone else has already found the answer and followed up with the appropriate thread.

I think a lot of folks join just to ask a quick question... they don't bother reading the rules, or the stickies (with instructions on how to search), and they have no desire to be a "part of the community". They have an attitude and have no desire to contribute. So they blindly post up a new thread. The "community" then posts on their thread with how to search and they get offended because someone was "rude" (by explaining how to search) or closed their thread (because there's already half a dozen of the same thread).

Using T4R on a PC is a much better experience than Tapatalk. The tapatalk app does not equate to actually using the T4R site on a computer. Not by a longshot.

Also.... there are a TON of threads started in the 5th Gen section that are A. not relevant to the 5th gen or B. Relavant to all generations of the 4Runner. THIS is the #1 reason why threads get moved. Because they are not relevant...

On the individual that started the thread that got out of hand and closed (re: Orange Boxx)... if you go to the classifieds section there is a specific thread that talks about experiences with vendors( http://www.toyota-4runner.org/feedback-sellers-buyers/ )... this would have been the appropriate place to start the subject. Yes I realize it was 5th gen related (sort of, but not really as it was in reference to the vendor and a product they produced and subsequent communication with said vendor). Orange Boxx makes things for several different models of Toyotas and generations of 4R, not just the 5th gen. While you may have felt your situation was specific to the 5th Gen, this is doubtful.

Soooo here's my last point... if you are ONLY using this forum via the Tapatalk App... you are missing out of the great plethora of information that is on the site as a whole. If you are too busy to "search" then you are truly not looking for a community to be part of. If you post up a new thread to ask a new question, you definitely did not read the rules or the stickies and you probably don't need to be here anymore. I have basically done my entire build without posting a "NEW" subject asking questions. The latest task is a dual battery setup... for me this was not easy (having no previous experience in electrical) but I have been able to get my wiring diagram done based on the information I found here by searching.

As was said by a previous poster, time is our most valuable asset. I am grateful of the time that [MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] has contributed to this community. IF he does go, I will be sad to see him leave. He has cleaned house which is what this (sub-) forum needed. A couple years ago I almost left, as I was personally attacked (see my previous post on this). But... I stuck it out and in the end I am glad I stayed. There is a wealth of knowledge and information here.... and I kinda like you guys.

:usa2:
 
Last edited:
I'm going to do just that once I have an update to share. The point of my post wasn't to complain either--the OP asked why threads get locked and I shared mine as an example (people going off-topic and arguing politics).

I think that would be best. It wasn't your fault that it went off-skids, and I thought your approach to the problem was solid. I hope all of that is getting worked out for you.
 
I don't do well with people who just cant understand basic STEM subjects.

No chance I could do my 13yr old son's math homework.

To all:
That said; I think the thing that makes the forum occasionally shitty is the same thing that makes it occasionally awesome. The people that contribute. When I started posting here, I thought most of my posts were helpful, and fit with what people were looking for. I'm sure if I look back on my first couple dozen posts now, I would think they are wastes of time.

This stuff isn't that important. I think most people here get that. It is an entertaining and informative place for enthusiasts to share information. Relax. If something here really makes you that upset, close your browser and go outside.

And for the love of all things holy, erase the 9 photos from the post you are quoting before posting your response. Also, this is one of a thousand places to resize/rotate your pictures before uploading:
Free Online Picture Resizer - Crop and Resize photos, images, or pictures online for FREE!
 
Last edited:
It’s a shame because 1E started out kind of ok. But the power obviously has gone to his head. First he deleted my poll: Phillyd2, Best T4R.ORG Member of the Century or Forever?. Then the jerk had the nerve to tell me that I could no longer charge money to answer PM questions from newbies. The final straw was when he wouldn’t allow me to post those pictures from the Cove even though everybody knows they were Tasteful Art. Next thing you know the punk will be invading Poland! Most likely on Bike.

tree_of_liberty_quote_t_jefferson_sticker_rect.jpg
 
[MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] I hope that you are not seriously considering leaving and it's just rumors. Many appreciate your general and personal contributions.. At the end of the day, nothing on this thread is fact... It's all opinions and personal outlook. Hope to keep seeing educational threads from you.

Plus I'm looking for you to upgrading to the gen 6 with a supercharger on 285s :nerd:
 
It’s a shame because 1E started out kind of ok. But the power obviously has gone to his head. First he deleted my poll: Phillyd2, Best T4R.ORG Member of the Century or Forever?. Then the jerk had the nerve to tell me that I could no longer charge money to answer PM questions from newbies. The final straw was when he wouldn’t allow me to post those pictures from the Cove even though everybody knows they were Tasteful Art. Next thing you know the punk will be invading Poland! Most likely on Bike.

tree_of_liberty_quote_t_jefferson_sticker_rect.jpg

I'm with [MENTION=6163]phillyd2[/MENTION] on this one. [MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] makes me put all my Sales Figure related information in one thread!

Forever-Alone_o_98121.gif
 
I hope you guys who wanted [MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] out of here are happy. Be careful what you wish for.
 
See, that's one of the biggest issues. A lot of folks don't use the google machine. On every single new thread that I have seen pop up, I go to Google, type in: 5th Gen T4r, (subject/question). 95-98% of the time, I find at least two or more threads on the subject (I also usually scroll through the thread to make sure there is pertinent info in there before pasting it into my response). The other 3-5% of the time I get back to the thread in question, and someone else has already found the answer and followed up with the appropriate thread.

Mind you, this comment is coming from someone who has not yet started a thread on the forum as I use the search function religiously; however, if there were 95-98% less threads on the forum for people who already found the answers, wouldn't this section be pretty slow?

It would basically have a handful of active threads... "let's see your xxx color 5th gen," and "what did you do to your 5th gen today?" etc. Then the other 3-5% of "new" topics, which would amount to a couple new threads a week.

Of course, maybe more people might bump existing threads, however to be honest, not only are there many duplicate threads of existing topics, but usually the existing threads already have the answers people are looking for as well.

Some duplicates get to be a bit much, but it's seriously not the end of the world. People can simply ignore duplicate threads instead of getting all butt hurt over it. Unfortunately it seems like some people take these mistakes as personal slights or something.
 
You got a lot of hate built up bro, for just 6 posts...

Your immaturity and insecurity is clearly evident in what you write. Did [MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] delete your prior posts....lol.

Anyway...the Mod job and climbing My. Everest are exactly alike for one good reason...time. They both require time to do a task.

Time is the one single most valuable resource we have that can't be replaced or duplicated.

So Greg spends his time trying daily to make this place better for everyone, with very little thanks.....even for whiney, crybaby douchebags like you.

I'm guessing that he's someone who was banned and re-registered under a new name. Happens all the time. Permanent bans here are passed out like candy. That's never good moderating, especially when people just register again with a new name.
 
[MENTION=66316]1engineer[/MENTION] I hope that you are not seriously considering leaving and it's just rumors. Many appreciate your general and personal contributions.. At the end of the day, nothing on this thread is fact... It's all opinions and personal outlook. Hope to keep seeing educational threads from you.

Plus I'm looking for you to upgrading to the gen 6 with a supercharger on 285s :nerd:

If 1engineer quits, i'm moving to Canada...........................:usa2: oh wait that was some other issue. :closed_2: :juggle:
 
Mind you, this comment is coming from someone who has not yet started a thread on the forum as I use the search function religiously; however, 1. if there were 95-98% less threads on the forum for people who already found the answers, wouldn't this section be pretty slow?

It would basically have a handful of active threads... "let's see your xxx color 5th gen," and "what did you do to your 5th gen today?" etc. 2. Then the other 3-5% of "new" topics, which would amount to a couple new threads a week.

Of course, 3. maybe more people might bump existing threads, however to be honest, not only are there many duplicate threads of existing topics, but usually the existing threads already have the answers people are looking for as well.

4. Some duplicates get to be a bit much, but it's seriously not the end of the world. 5. People can simply ignore duplicate threads instead of getting all butt hurt over it. Unfortunately it seems like some people take these mistakes as personal slights or something.

1. No... they would post in the original thread, asking the same question or variant thereof.

2. Yes, it would slow traffic for "new" threads.... after 7 years in this generation, there should rarely be anything ground breaking "new".

3. Yes, this is the general idea. Revive a thread that possibly has a right answer. Or revive a thread that was on the right track to ask more detailed information.

4. I agree. When looking for something specific, and finding many duplicates on a subject, I usually end up in the build threads, because at one point, all the things I am looking for WERE groundbreaking.

5. Herein lies the problem... when new threads are started and they have dead ends, all the searching that I did that turns up 6 different threads is a waste of time, because now I have to dig through 6 different threads to find 4 or 5 dead ends, and 1 or 2 threads that are relevant to what I'm searching for.
 
Last edited:
5. Herein lies the problem... when new threads are started and they have dead ends, all the searching a I did that turns up 6 different threads is a waste of time, because now I have to dig through 6 different threads to find 4 or 5 dead ends, and 1 or 2 threads that are relevant to what I'm searching for.

An Example: it took me 5-6 months of going through "What's this noise" threads before I found out that the fender liner was causing the noise in my lower dash and foot well! Ask [MENTION=65614]Antman[/MENTION] - this "little noise" was beyond annoying and near impossible to track down. A few weeks ago I finally spent several hours pouring through unresolved noise threads to find a thread from 2012 that outlined the problem.

...3 zip ties later, my truck is quiet again.
 
An Example: it took me 5-6 months of going through "What's this noise" threads before I found out that the fender liner was causing the noise in my lower dash and foot well! Ask [MENTION=65614]Antman[/MENTION] - this "little noise" was beyond annoying and near impossible to track down. A few weeks ago I finally spent several hours pouring through unresolved noise threads to find a thread from 2012 that outlined the problem.

...3 zip ties later, my truck is quiet again.

Maybe we should have an official "what's that noise thread" or merge all the existing ones together?

I find it crazy that you honestly spent 5-6 months searching for solutions, and then again, several hours, looking at how to fix your problem instead of starting a new thread.

Were you seriously THAT against starting a new thread? You don't feel that maybe after an hour or two you'd be justified in starting a new thread?

The more I think about it, it's rather comical. Maybe you were too frightened to start a new thread out of fear that the mod-god would come down with the warning hammer when your "questions has already been answered in another thread." Seriously.. It's pretty bad if that's what point this forum is at..

I just got my 4runner and joined a month ago, and coming from someone who has modded a lot of vehicles in my life, I have had a ton of questions. Fortunately, with some searching I have been able to answer most all of them. I will probably start a build thread soon as a way to document the build and ask specific opinions, but if I had a problem that was as severe as yours, and I searched as much as you said, I certainly wouldn't shy away from starting a thread about it...
 
Last edited:
Maybe we should have an official "what's that noise thread" or merge all the existing ones together?

I find it crazy that you honestly spent 5-6 months searching for solutions, and then again, several hours, looking at how to fix your problem instead of starting a new thread.

Were you seriously THAT against starting a new thread? You don't feel that maybe after an hour or two you'd be justified in starting a new thread?

The more I think about it, it's rather comical. Maybe you were too frightened to start a new thread out of fear that the mod-god would come down with the warning hammer when your "questions has already been answered in another thread." Seriously.. It's pretty bad if that's what point this forum is at..

I just got my 4runner and joined a month ago, and coming from someone who has modded a lot of vehicles in my life, I have had a ton of questions. Fortunately, with some searching I have been able to answer most all of them. I will probably start a build thread soon as a way to document the build and ask specific opinions, but if I had a problem that was as severe as yours, and I searched as much as you said, I certainly wouldn't shy away from starting a thread about it...

Sounds like you just volunteered to be the new mod. Congrats.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,310
Messages
3,554,080
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top