I guess it depends on what your needs are when it comes to tire decision. From the looks of it, the crosstek seems to lean more toward a highway tire, so I'm sure it would be more on the quiet side compared to the at3. I also have been pleased with my AT3's, but you might also want to look at the terra grappler if its an AT tire you want. Those seem to have quite a fanbase on here & get good reviews.
