My last 3 optima red tops all failed within 1-2 years. Each time one of the six cells went bad. I kept getting them replaced under warranty until I got rid of the car. BTW, this was in a regular DD car with no extra loads or etc. I don't know much about their SLA offerings since they do not have a huge market share in the US but Panasonic is the best when it comes to li-ion and I would much rather have a made in Japan SLA product over something slapped together in Mexico.
IMO just stay away from ANYTHING made by Johnson Controls. They have ~80% market share in the US and are behind almost every brand that you will find. Most of these products will only vary by the case and warranty. They have also shifted most of the production to Mexico and the quality control really seems to be lacking.
Whats left in the US is East Penn (Deka, Car Quest, some O'Reily), Enersys (Odyssey, Diehard platinum), and Exide (in BK right now)