Great video indeed.
I know that toyota has the recess spec, but it would seem that the depth in which you set the seal at can play into weather or not it seals up fully to a non-OEM axle (e.g. remanufatured, NAPA, etc.) My seals are not old, but they leaked after I installed a remanufactured axle.
My approach will be to test fit the new seal on the axle once its removed, observe/note the existing seal's depth in the diff., and then set the new seal at a depth less than where it currently sits...reinstall the axle, ensure that there isn't any interference with the seal and the cv housing where it meets the diff, and hope that my leak has been fixed.
I will do my best to follow-up with at the very least a result to what I ended up with, and at best maybe a few pictures along with my results.
Thanks to everyone for sharing your experiences and knowledge on this forum.
Just following up as promised, I believe I've been successful with the new seal on the passenger side. I was having a slow leak after installing toyota remanufactured axles, and we told by the dealership that I'd just need to go with a new seal and a OEM axle to get it to seal (as I described above).
Here's what I did, and I believe it was suggested as a solution in this thread, so I'm not claiming the solution as mine. The factory seal sits flush with the inner lip in the differential, where the axle meets up to it, and I measure that at 5.5-6mm from the outermost edge of the diff.
I pulled the axle, and looked at where the seal had been 'seating', which was a little further out than I expected.
I Test fitted a new seal to ensure that it felt snug...which it felt a little lose to me, but I also don't have the best feel for this being my first time replacing this seal, so I went with it. I didn't feel or observe any gaps, excessive play, and figured it wasn't meant to be 'tight' for the sake of wear and tear.
I pulled the old seal out and seated the new seal just shy of the recommended depth. I followed up with measuring to see where I was: roughly 4.75mm. Visually you could see that it wasn't all the way in, BUT by now means did it seem that it would come out easy...I had to seat it that far using a hammer and the right diameter race. I trusted I wasn't going anywhere.
I reinstalled the axle, topped off the gear oil, and went to a friends house about a half hour away, using both back roads and highway (35-70mph).
I checked the bottom of the diff last night, and this morning to find that my leak has, thus far, been fixed.