Man you guys are brutal... let's be really clear, and add some color here.
1. I've owned probably 20 toyotas/lexii - of those 20 I've had 4 4runners, and 2GX's, in addition to those I've had 1 LX470, an LX450, and 2 L100 series land cruisers - so when I say the 5th gen was the worst of those, I feel like I'm coming from a position of experience - BUT I'm not knocking the 5th in comparison to OTHER non toyota options please note that. I would bet I have more than a million miles in the vehicles listed above, so believe me when I tell you I know what kind of quality to expect. By far the best experience we have had was an 07 v8 sport 4x4... in fact if i had been able to find one with decent miles I would have considered going back to one. In the driveway today I have a 97 supra turbo, a 2001 GS430, and now the L200.
2. Any smart guy who thinks a 30 minute test drive, or spending 10 minutes in the cabin oohing and ahhhing all the features is enough to REALLY get to know a vehicle is either prophetic or sadly mistaken. No dealer in their right mind is going to let me take the 4runner for a week, tow my supra to a race, and in general put it through my daily abuse. So to assume I was an uneducated or under read buyer is an abhorrent statement - I made a FAIR assumption that because we had had great experiences with OTHER 4runners we would have no less of a great experience with this one. For that I was wrong.
3. The towing capacity of 5000 lbs is a joke, my open trailer and car weight in right at 4400 ish, and in order to tow that my foot was on the floor the entire time. Is it DOABLE yes, is it safe? I didn't think so - so regardless of what the brochure says (which I still have and read MANY times) - there is no way to know how a vehicle will handle that until you do it. Yes there are things I could have done to compensate, load leveling hitches, air bags, etc... but that would not have dealt with the lack of available power.
4. The gas mileage is what it is, I really don't care if anyone believes me. We reset the counter after EVERY tank and left the eco light on - Our 4runner suffered from being a soccer mom car, lots of stop and go, to and from school, practices, etc - we generally get a bit below advertised for our family vehicle - but even I didn't expect it to be as low as it was.
I do find it funny that so many people take offense at my statements, I didn't state the 4runner was a bad vehicle, a bad bargain or a bad option - just simply stated why *I* personally was not happy with it. The fact still remains that a 5th gen 4R is still a better investment than most, will be more reliable than most, and will hold resell better than most
I wouldn't have replied at all except all the haters saying dumb crap like "well the OP must not have test drove" or "well did the OP not sit in the vehicle"... seriously stuff like that is just dumb, I'd wager I've owned more Toyota vehicles and driven more miles in them than MOST on this forum and making assumptions about my level of education or lack of preparation just shows you're angry, possibly ignorant, and went full ruh-**** in a post that was expressing an opinion you didn't like.
The 5th gen is still a great vehicle, but it's not for me.
now to be 100% fair, I will say that the new L200 LC also suffers from some of the same downfalls as the latest 4runner - the interior quality and materials are a significant step down, certainly lower than our 2004 L100, however it's thoroughly modern, the 5.7L v8 is great, and the 6spd auto does a fantastic job. The tow rating of 8500 is realistic. I have some of the same complaints about the L200 that I lobbed against the 5th gen - the difference is that it fits better for us and our lifestyle over all making it easier to overlook the quality change.
Both the 5th gen and the LC are more than 100% capable for any off road we do (light camping, SUV trails, nothing crazy) and both resells are off the charts so net net it's a solid wash for me.
I am absolutely a fan of previous L's but my motorsports ventures are speed/track related not offroad so the changes from L80 to L100 to L200 being less and less capable offroad don't concern me as much as it might some. The primary reason the L200 is the least sold SUV in the states is because toyota has done a terrible job marketing it and MOST *US* buyers would prefer to buy a platinum sequoia for 10k$ less... the Lx570 is sold something liek 5:1 over the land cruiser and it can sticker close to 95k, but lexus does a great job advertising it as a premium SUV option.
I didn't expect to start a 90+ reply thread, but at least SOME of the discussion has been useful.
regards,
-Zach