A less popular comment about secularism
Let's start by defining secularism as the complete separation of church and state, in particular NO RELIGIOUS LAWS and no limitations on freedoms in the name of protecting religion, eg blasphemy laws. America is a secular democratic republic.
So there are many people in America who embrace secularism. The problem comes when people reject secularism and feel oppressed by a Western secular society.
One question at hand: Is it possible for someone or a group that completely rejects secularism to live a compatible life in western society?
Christianity and Judaism have overwhelmingly embraced secularism for at least the last 100 years, both in the US and Europe. When you look at the countries in the middle East only Turkey is secular and that is fading fast.
How did Turkey become secular? Its a good question to ponder.
The answer is the Ottoman Turks ruled over the Islamic society by force and locked up or killed any members of the Turkish population who did not accept the government's secular ways. There were always religiously conservative people in Turkey who did not want secularism but the Ottoman Turks banned them from government, shut down radical Mosques, and locked up or killed religious agitators. They also passed harsh laws against public expression of religion such as wearing a face covering. A key take away is that Turkey's secularism wasn't democratic, it was by force of arms and government regulation.
What about the other countries in the middle East? I don't see a lot of secularism out there. The middle East for the most part is still deciding it's future. Will it be secular or religious? The question is far from settled.