i have 265-70s on my 17x9's and haven't really noticed it looking like that. im not that picky anyway. will have to look in the daylight tomorrow to see if i can really notice it
It's your money, it's your car - do what you want. Obviously you're more concerned with appearance, so do what pleases your eye. If you're really worried about stretching the tire too much on a wider wheel, then get a narrower wheel. Pretty simple.
FWIW, I looked up the Duratracs in stock size. LT versions are recommended for 7"-8.5" widths. The non-LT version is recommended for 7"-9" widths (which would cover your 17x9 wheel). If it were my money, I'd be sticking to the tire manufacturer's recommendations and call it a day.
Yes sir, the tires I am going with are rated for up to 9". So, what I am concerned with is wether that will give the look I want to avoid. The rims we want (2 choices now) are only available in 9" width. I am trying to use this forum as a resource to see pics of that combo since there is usually no way to confirm a rim size on a vehicle spotted on the road or in a parking lot. Don't want to make this purchase and then say "oh, that is what I was afraid of".
No, but what you CAN do is research instead of just asking. Your wheel you want is 9" correct? Go to my chart or go to the tire website and look for section width and tread width. Tread width is not normally shown but section width is. That's the width of the sidewall bulges. If your chosen tire has a 11" section width then you will have a 1" bulge on either side ((11-9)/2) so your tire won't have a "flat" sidewall going up to the tread.
Your chart is where I started. Well, more so in researching offset. Please see my thread on "trail rim offset", (not sure how to give you a link here) and check my math.
Your research doesn't have to be Toyota specific. Google images of the tires you want and nine inch rims. You'll find a ton of results. Also, you'll want a more narrow rim or wider tire, 265 on a nine inch rim is going to give you the look you don't want.
Give me your rim and tire spec.
BFG rugged terrain P265/70R17
10.7 section width
8.4 tread width
31.7 overall diam
Ultra Baron 17x9
+12mm offset
5.39 backspace
*tirerack.com recommends 265/70/17 with this rim for the 2014 4runner