17Apr2020 95,3xx mi
It's been a while since I've posted, but 6-day weeks will kill any ability to do anything but spend money on the truck! I finally got back under the hood for a bit. Sure it wasn't much, but it's a start.
I'd noticed in early winter that my XenonDepot HID kit didn't seem quite at bright, it no longer washed out the city lights. Over several weeks, I manged a small conversation with XD. Between us we figure the bulbs were nearing the end of their life, as I drive dark hours at least half of my work commutes. They explained the bulbs are only supposed to be good for about 2500 hours, even the Philips (which I've heard last longer than the XenonDepot brand). So I ordered a replacement set, installed 1 bulb (1 arrived damaged), and drove it to work the next morning. I didn't even make it out of the subdivision before I decided it wasn't going to work. The new bulb, even though was a Philips V2 wasn't anywhere near as bright (5000k vs 4300k), and for some reason the hot spot was aimed at the road directly in front of the truck. I fiddled with it thinking that I hadn't gotten the bulb fully seated, tried switching to the other side (similar results), and even installed the damaged bulb (which appeared functional, though not durable) and got the same result. Maybe they got a bad batch or I'm just the unlucky guy, but at $175 for a pair of bulbs I wasn't willing to tolerate disappointment! The new bulb came back out, along with the 7443 Switchback LED I tried on driver front parking light/turn signal that wasn't as bright as a much older DDM Tuning. After some effort I got a hold of XenonDepot's customer service, and they did right by me. Customer service win, although I wish it had been much faster as there was usually a week to 1.5 weeks between responses unless you managed to get them on the phone. This process completed sometime in February, and I was researching options.
Going back to halogen was out, not bright enough for backwoods TN, though the least expensive option. Another HID bulb could be an option, but which one to try? Most of the connectors were different, so it would mean replacing the entire kit. Then 3-4 years down the road I'd be right back at the same place, bulbs slowly dimming and expensive converted bulbs. I considered the fancy triple projector LED whole headlight replacement only as long as it took to find people having trouble with it and complaining about output. Real conversion to HID seemed possible and not terribly expensive, however, without time to really work on the truck, and a need to order a 2nd set of headlights to accomplish it, it wasn't so affordable any more. And that left just a regular LED replacement. This was the most appealing, and ultimate choice for cost and longevity. Fifteen times the rated lifespan of the HID at about the same cost for a premium set. I'm very much the buy once, cry once type. Better to pay for quality and not have to do it all over again. So back to the all in one lighting company, XenonDepot, Headlight Revolution, Morimoto, GTR Lighting, and several others (now all owned and operated as the same). I also browsed some of the DDM Tuning options, but they seemed too big to fit in the housing with the dust seal. The new GTR Ultra2's were highly rated, fit the housing, and were soon to be available. I also found a
thread here that verified fitment of the later generations. While hesitant to order from the all-in-one company with frustrating customer service delays, I eventually pulled the trigger. I also ordered new dust/weather caps from Toyota for about $20 as I had drilled mine for the XD HID kit.
I actually spent more time removing the old HID kit given how hidden, tucked, and zip-tied it was installed. I didn't get every bit of the double sided adhesive up, but will go back and attack it later. The GTR Ultra2 installation was straight forward, even made easy by the fact that polarity was marked on the connector! It's always the little touches like this that impress me.
EDIT 21May20 95,9xx mi: It's been a couple of months driving with these, and it's time for a follow up. My weekly mileage is down due to the COVID panic and a reduced work schedule, but I'm still driving mostly night time. They are in a 3/9 orientation so that the chips are facing directly forward and rearward in the housing. I haven't attempted to reorient them and see if I get better results. I had to aim the headlights back up some, I think because the focal point shifted in the projector between the HID & LED. I quickly realized the Ultra2 are not as bright down the road as the HID kit was due to color temp and intensity. I do like the instant on to full brightness, no waiting for the bulbs to warm up in cold weather temperatures. I was mostly sold on the longevity of these, though now I can't find any published lifespan for them. But I shouldn't need a replacement unless something better comes along.
HID/LED comparison. XenonDepot Xtreme HID w/Philips 4300k vs GTR Ultra 2
Color: HID 4300k, LED 6000k. Though most don't like the lower color temperature, it does have a higher CRI, and appears brighter. Point HID.
Intensity: Side by side at close range against the garage door you can see the intensity is pretty close. Down a dark wet road and at a distance of 300-500ft the HID were more intense. Point HID.
Beam Pattern: Full and wide with no hot spots on either. Draw.
Startup: Even with the relays, the HIDs could take anywhere from 5 seconds to 2 minutes to reach full brightness, longer the later into their lifespan they get or colder it was outside. The LED are instant on, and will be until they fail. Point LED.
Lifespan: HID 2500, LED no specs published. Most quality LED will run 40,000 hours. Theoretically the point should go to LED.
Cost: HID Kit $150+, Ultra2 $200. Draw. By the time you pay for the significantly better upgrade to the Philips HID bulbs you're at the $200 mark on either. I've installed the XD bulbs that come standard and they just aren't as full or as bright as the Philips.
Installation: LED plug & play, fits entirely inside dust covers. HID, remove battery, drill dust covers, mount ballasts, install relays, wires all over need zip tied, be careful not to touch the bulbs. Philips though the original 4300k v1 bulbs have a right angle base, the newer 5000k v2 bulbs don't which makes required torque application extremely difficult. Point LED.
Fitment: HID has a thick rubber collar which makes installation difficult. LED twist in without difficulty. Point LED.
Tally: Color - HID, Intensity - HID, Pattern - Draw, Startup - LED, Lifespan - LED, Cost - Draw, Install - LED, Fit - LED.
Honestly if you're looking for the brightest installation out there and recurring bulb costs don't bother you, HID should be your choice. I got almost 4 years out of my HID install before it started getting dimmer, and even sent the old bulbs along with the kit to the new buyer who said they are still working in his install. At least half of my drive time is night, and I estimate the bulbs were closer to 3000 hours of use before I removed them. If you're looking for significant improvement over OEM, and a simple install with a "buy once, cry once" attitude then go LED. /Edit
Here's the GTR Ultra2 LED on the driver with the old XD HID 35w w/Philips 4300k on passenger for a side by side.
And GTR Ultra2 LED on both sides. I've not taken it out for a drive yet. I feel like I need at least a semi legitimate reason to leave the house nowadays with COVID19. I don't expect issues, and love the instant on at full bright that LED has over the bulb warm up on the HID's.
A while back I had a shop fab me up a mount for the fuse block. I didn't get to wiring it today, but started moving things around to make it easier when I do. It's now much simpler to get the battery in and out. Although with the supercharger and intercooler, there's not any room left between the factory fuse box and the inner fender to go running wires. I might be running some up where I had the HID ballasts stuffed, on top of the inner fender under the plastic supporting the rubber hood seal. But that's to come later. There is more wiring for me this week, but it will be doing a full LED conversion and re-wiring the boat trailer. The only good thing about COVID (aside from not getting it), has been the reduced work schedule which is allowing me to catch up on all these projects. Hopefully there will be more posts in the near future!
