I recently went from K&N back to a paper (STP brand) filter - and now and getting 40 miles less per tank.
Was at 280 now I'm at 240.
It's extremely hard to believe that a filter change caused that. I'd be looking for something else wrong if I were you.
Any ideas? That's the only thing I've changed. Driving habits are the same.
I def need a new fuel filter.
Stop measuring mpg by the tank. Do miles driven over gallons consumed from one fill-up to the next, filling exactly the same way. Just doing it by the tank is too imprecise.