Did you go with the Cooper ATP's? I really thought about getting those (probably should have), but heard they run small.
Yeah - I research everything I buy to death, and knew these tires had excellent reviews. What I failed to remember was stumbling across the one or two posts across the entire internet about them running small. It's 100% true, and a guy from Cooper called me this morning to chat. First thing he did was calculate the size of the 285/75/16, which he mentioned was 32.8 (I knew this).
Second, he looked up the OD of the ATP, which ended up being 32.5something (I also learned this yesterday after purchasing, but had to do a live chat with someone at Discount Tire Direct). So yeah, they do run .3" below average while some 285's end up being a full 33" (or some a hair bigger even). I measured my rear tire yesterday for fun and while the method may not be perfect, it appears it's maybe 1/32" under 32", inflated to 37 PSI, from ground to the very top of the tread. Dead level concrete slab.
Oddly enough my Dynapro LT265/75/16's with ~6k miles on them are quieter than these new tires, maybe rubber compound? I don't doubt that they're a great tire, but the a) undersizing, b) rather bland sidewalls, even compared to dynapro, and c) blender noise they produce is enough for me to return them to Discount Tire. Picked up my old stuff this morning in my Tacoma and talked to a sales guy, he's totally cool with me exchanging. Will be going for possibly Duratrac, or whatever I land on after a couple hours of research and beers this evening.