I think the problem is the fundamentally the V8 and getting back to a nice multimode Torsen on all trims. To me these were a real step back.
While there is a lot of backroad/mountain/offroad use of the 4Runner (and this should be one of its main niches) most of us need to get there. That means hours on the highway, often towing something modest. This is where the lack of a V8 is the most noticed.
The travel/camping (sport utility you know) is were compromises should not be made. I really notice the lack of torque on the highway with any wind and my modest trailer, never mind going though the mountains. Heck even with just a ski box it is ridiculous for the thing to have to kick down to third in order to maintain speed on a modest grade. Sometimes I actually think I'm driving my Yaris.
Now poorer aerodynamics in Gen5 vs Gen4 probably have something to do with it but a friend of mine with the Gen4 V8 gets consistently better highway mileage than I do. I think most of us would burn the same amount of gas, or potentially less, with an efficient V8.
Plus seeing a putrid little Durango with a 5.7 Hemi (cylinder deactivation or even hybrid!) in it just angry's me up! :mmph: