5th Gen Engine Oil Leak at 50k

I just took it to an independent repair shop - he confirmed it's the timing cover. Estimate - $2000. Oh yay! Now I just have to decide if/when to do this. He said it's one of the worst leaks he's seen. Also, need to decide whether to cancel diagnostic appointment at the dealer - cost will be $130 and I already know what the problem is.
Did they use die, or just do a visual inspection? Is it leaking enough to drip on the ground? There's a couple other possible sources in that area - valve cover gasket or VVTI high pressure hose, both of which are cheap and easy fixes.

Generally, if it is the timing cover, it is a minor weap more than a leak, as it is not under pressure or in an area that oil pools. Some have reported success by smearing RTV on the outside of the union of the timing cover, head, and block. I just did this to mine last week so the survey is still out on if it will fix it for me.

Doing the proper repair is a pretty big job; doing it the ghetto way just involves removing the 3 bolts for the power steering pump, degreasing the area, and smearing some RTV on.
 
I just took it to an independent repair shop - he confirmed it's the timing cover. Estimate - $2000. Oh yay! Now I just have to decide if/when to do this. He said it's one of the worst leaks he's seen. Also, need to decide whether to cancel diagnostic appointment at the dealer - cost will be $130 and I already know what the problem is.

I would read post #41. in this thread.

Some more below about the RTV:

post #7 in the following thread
2006 Tacoma Suspected Power Steering Return Line | Tacoma World

post #22
Front main seal leaking?? | Page 2 | Tacoma World

post #182399
What Have You Done To Your 2nd Gen Tacoma Today? | Page 9120 | Tacoma World
 
Last edited:
... removing the 3 bolts for the power steering pump, degreasing the area, and smearing some RTV on.

Check torque on timing cover bolts, degrease with brake cleaner, and blow with dry compressed air. Use RTV that's flexible and highly oil resistant such as Permatex ultra black maximum oil resistance RTV silicone. Check PCV valve and its vacuum line.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, 0W20 is ONLY to meet CAFE standards. (MPG)

You cannot prove that. It may well be true, but Toyota has not said so. So it is your opinion.

But I don't want to really get into it here...

Well then what happened? Tourette's syndrome? Computer possessed? Were you hacked by the anti-0w-20-Industrial-Complex? Somebody have a gun to your head?

I'm thinking you dragged this thread off-topic because you really did 'want to get into it here.'

This is a thread about oil leaks, not your personal choice to disregard your owner's manual and your apparent desire for company in doing so.
 
You cannot prove that. It may well be true, but Toyota has not said so. So it is your opinion.



Well then what happened? Tourette's syndrome? Computer possessed? Were you hacked by the anti-0w-20-Industrial-Complex? Somebody have a gun to your head?

I'm thinking you dragged this thread off-topic because you really did 'want to get into it here.' ��

This is a thread about oil leaks, not your personal choice to disregard your owner's manual and your apparent desire for company in doing so.


See the thread in what you quoted.



Page 465 in the owners manual.
"SAE 0W-20 is the best choice for good fuel economy and good starting in cold weather. If SAE 0W-20 is not available,SAE 5W-20 oil may be used.However, it must be replaced with SAE 0W-20 at the next oil change"
Except Puerto Rico.
https://www.toyota.com/t3Portal/document/om-s/OM35B46U/pdf/OM35B46U.pdf

Why is that? What do they use there? 0W8?:hiding:
What if we don't live where it gets cold?
Say like in the UAE where they recommend 5W30 through 15W40 for the SAME engine.
Page 832/833 https://nd-auto-styles-temp-product...__EN_OM_OM0K451E_(GE)_01-1905-00_bookmark.pdf
Replicate via this link Owners Manual


:flamethrwoer2::flamethrwoer2::flamethrwoer2:


And I suggested to the user to use a thicker oil which MAY help slow the leak, and depending on the base, may help slow it even more.
She doesn't seem to have the cash or know-how to DIY.
After all, we are not all swimming in pools of money, so I made the easiest, most obvious suggestion for her to try and see if it slows.


Here is one from Australia. Page 338 and scroll up 1 page to see the info is for the 1GR.
https://toyotamanuals.com.au/docs/fj-cruiser-owners-manual-aug-14-current/
 
Last edited:
I have a 2005 4runer. At 10 years old (150,000 miles) I tried a synthetic oil and got many "drips" around the oil pan (and above). I switched back to conventional (NAPA 10W - 30) and the drips slowed down to about two drips every month.

I will not use synthetic oil in my 4 runner ever again.

Scotty Kilmer says it can cause problems in older engines. Watch the whole video. scotty kilmer on synthetic oil leaks in older cars - Bing video
 
I have a 2005 4runer. At 10 years old (150,000 miles) I tried a synthetic oil and got many "drips" around the oil pan (and above). I switched back to conventional (NAPA 10W - 30) and the drips slowed down to about two drips every month.

I will not use synthetic oil in my 4 runner ever again.

Scotty Kilmer says it can cause problems in older engines. Watch the whole video. scotty kilmer on synthetic oil leaks in older cars - Bing video



Esther based oils will usually swell seals a bit.
PAO bases can shrink seals.
 
Did they use die, or just do a visual inspection? Is it leaking enough to drip on the ground? There's a couple other possible sources in that area - valve cover gasket or VVTI high pressure hose, both of which are cheap and easy fixes.

Generally, if it is the timing cover, it is a minor weap more than a leak, as it is not under pressure or in an area that oil pools. Some have reported success by smearing RTV on the outside of the union of the timing cover, head, and block. I just did this to mine last week so the survey is still out on if it will fix it for me.

Doing the proper repair is a pretty big job; doing it the ghetto way just involves removing the 3 bolts for the power steering pump, degreasing the area, and smearing some RTV on.

Thanks, Jeremy. It is a weep - not a leak. Apparently no drips hitting the ground - at least not yet. I trust the guy who did the visual inspection - he seemed to know what he was doing. I cancelled the diagnostic appointment at the dealer. Post back when you know more about whether the RTV worked. By the way, I am in Grand Junction! At this point, I am planning to wait and see. I need to put some cardboard under the engine to confirm it's not dripping. Dealer quote was $2700 just for labor.
 
Try not to be bummed about this. If there is any vehicle worth going after leaks and getting things fixed up, it is your 4Runner. Make sure you have top notch mechanic and they give you a year warranty on the work. Sometimes leaks take a few passes to get right.

I really appreciate your comment. The mechanic who looked at it does offer a one year/12k warranty. My gut tells me to just get it fixed. But, even the mechanic said I don't have to do anything at this point as it's not dripping onto the ground. My brother (backyard mechanic) and my husband (armchair mechanic) both said I should wait. My husband has been putting a quart of oil in his '95 Ford truck every 1500 miles for years. But, I'm not sure I have the patience for that! I want to look at my baby and know she's in tip top shape!!
 
See the thread in what you quoted.



Page 465 in the owners manual.
"SAE 0W-20 is the best choice for good fuel economy and good starting in cold weather. If SAE 0W-20 is not available,SAE 5W-20 oil may be used.However, it must be replaced with SAE 0W-20 at the next oil change"
Except Puerto Rico.
https://www.toyota.com/t3Portal/document/om-s/OM35B46U/pdf/OM35B46U.pdf

Why is that? What do they use there? 0W8?:hiding:
What if we don't live where it gets cold?
Say like in the UAE where they recommend 5W30 through 15W40 for the SAME engine.
Page 832/833 https://nd-auto-styles-temp-product...__EN_OM_OM0K451E_(GE)_01-1905-00_bookmark.pdf
Replicate via this link Owners Manual


:flamethrwoer2::flamethrwoer2::flamethrwoer2:


And I suggested to the user to use a thicker oil which MAY help slow the leak, and depending on the base, may help slow it even more.
She doesn't seem to have the cash or know-how to DIY.
After all, we are not all swimming in pools of money, so I made the easiest, most obvious suggestion for her to try and see if it slows.


Here is one from Australia. Page 338 and scroll up 1 page to see the info is for the 1GR.
https://toyotamanuals.com.au/docs/fj-cruiser-owners-manual-aug-14-current/

Don't derail this thread please. If she wants to join your Church of Higher Viscosity, she knows where to find it.
 
Last edited:
I really appreciate your comment. The mechanic who looked at it does offer a one year/12k warranty. My gut tells me to just get it fixed. But, even the mechanic said I don't have to do anything at this point as it's not dripping onto the ground. My brother (backyard mechanic) and my husband (armchair mechanic) both said I should wait. My husband has been putting a quart of oil in his '95 Ford truck every 1500 miles for years. But, I'm not sure I have the patience for that! I want to look at my baby and know she's in tip top shape!!

Go to the dealer and get their offer. Do not tell them what your mechanic said, as to cause or cost estimate. Just see what they say.
 
Last edited:
Go to the dealer and get their offer. Do not tell them what your mechanic said, as to cause or cost estimate. Just see what they say.

I agree. I just re-scheduled the diagnostic appointment. I also spent an hour or so watching the YouTube video on how to re-do the timing cover seal. Wow. So much labor. It's so hard to find someone to trust to take the engine completely apart. Not sure if I trust the dealer or the independent guy.

Anyway, I will take it in on Monday and get the dealer take on it. I will ask them to confirm for me where the leak is. (I think I can see it) I imagine the area will be clean after they have checked it out. Then, I can watch and see if it worsens - and how fast. I just want to be able to keep an eye on it.

As for the oil weight debate - I'm all for any regs to clean our air. I will go with what's in the manual.
 
Thanks, Jeremy. It is a weep - not a leak. Apparently no drips hitting the ground - at least not yet. I trust the guy who did the visual inspection - he seemed to know what he was doing. I cancelled the diagnostic appointment at the dealer. Post back when you know more about whether the RTV worked. By the way, I am in Grand Junction! At this point, I am planning to wait and see. I need to put some cardboard under the engine to confirm it's not dripping. Dealer quote was $2700 just for labor.
Hey neighbor. I would drive it and not worry. Maybe spray some degreaser and use a car wash sprayer every couple months. Mine's been leaking for at least 100k miles and I only now got around to trying to reseal the outside because I was doing some work in the same general area of the engine.

I doubt it ever drips. The oil comes out very slowly, only when the engine is running, and the wind through the engine compartment does a great job of spreading it all around the front right corner of the engine.

Had a 2nd gen Tacoma with the same problem and fixed it correctly. Decided it was not worth the effort again unless I need to pull the timing cover for something more serious.
 
I agree. I just re-scheduled the diagnostic appointment. I also spent an hour or so watching the YouTube video on how to re-do the timing cover seal. Wow. So much labor. It's so hard to find someone to trust to take the engine completely apart. Not sure if I trust the dealer or the independent guy.

Anyway, I will take it in on Monday and get the dealer take on it. I will ask them to confirm for me where the leak is. (I think I can see it) I imagine the area will be clean after they have checked it out. Then, I can watch and see if it worsens - and how fast. I just want to be able to keep an eye on it.

As for the oil weight debate - I'm all for any regs to clean our air. I will go with what's in the manual
.


and you are driving an oil leaking 19mpg 4Runner of all things??
lol
 
and you are driving an oil leaking 19mpg 4Runner of all things??
lol

Ouch!! You make a very good point. I enjoy driving the 4 Runner a ton, and need it to tow a camper. I know we will have to experience some pain to deal with climate change ... I hope that someday humans come up with a sustainable solution. I do see an electric vehicle in my future. I totally appreciate your comment!!
 
Last edited:
I do see an electric vehicle in my future.

I also see an electric vehicle in my future ... when something similar in size to the 4Runner reaches the market. Electric vehicle technology is evolving quickly. Toyota is working on a solid state battery which could become a significant development.
 
Ouch!! You make a very good point. I enjoy driving the 4 Runner a ton, and need it to tow a camper. I know we will have to experience some pain to deal with climate change ... I hope that someday humans come up with a sustainable solution. I do see an electric vehicle in my future. I totally appreciate your comment!!


That is a good point, isn't it. I used to be involved in the "climate field".
It was when I started talking about how glaciers once covered NYC to about two miles thick, deposited glacial erratics all over Central Park and carved out the Finger Lakes and how solar cycles dictated freeze/thaw cycles that they started trying to break my chops.
Like any field where someone dares speak out against, you are not welcome anymore.

In fact, we are on the rebound side to the ice age.
We won't be around to see it, unless our carbon is recycled quickly back into new life, but that is how they justify their jobs and create HUGE streams of revenue.

I think is it better for the environment to have things that last a LONG time.
In 15 years, I went through two refrigerators.
I still have a 1950's Philco in my basement that has never had an issue.
But it is a manual defrost.

If the EPA really cared, we would not be doing business with China and India.

I was part of a design team for ocean-going vessels to clean up floating plastic. Think almost like a whaling ship with a huge grinder to mince the plastic so more volume can fit in the hull.
Problem is the cost. There is no money to be made doing that, only expended.

We can go into how the Earth is a giant recycling facility and how the sun is dying and one day will engulf the planet, but this is a 4Runner forum.
Some pretty cool people on board here trying to share knowledge and logic.

Hence why I buy Toyota exclusively since 1999 and forgo 0.1-2 MPG to get 500k+ out of a vehicle by using an oil that will better protect.
I can buy a new cheap Kia every four years, or keep my Toyota's running for two decades.
The less parts that break, the less in landfills and recycling energy expended.


Anywho... Have a wonderful New Year.
 
I also see an electric vehicle in my future ... when something similar in size to the 4Runner reaches the market. Electric vehicle technology is evolving quickly. Toyota is working on a solid state battery which could become a significant development.


They can embed rails into highways in one lane, where you can charge on the go and break off if you want to go faster or exit and be charged a road-use/electric use fee based on an RFID chip embedded into the vehicle that transmits when being charged via the rail.
I mean, we already have self-driving cars which is half of the solution.

Once the tax per mile comes into play, that is the beginning of the end for a majority of internal combustion engines.

Then, we just need to build more nuclear plants. One meltdown though... Ugh.
Solar panels are black for a reason. But black absorbs the most radiation making the immediate area warmer.
Plus the fact that the clearcutting of forests to install solar...
Ever walk into or out of a forest on a hot day? Very cool in the forest compared to an open field.
 
Last edited:
Dude.

The science is settled.

Anything to the contrary is heresy.

Not sure I get you as that can be taken two ways.
Since your previous comments, I should take that as a dig?

If so, please feel free to debunk anything I said about the Finger Lakes, Glacial Erratics and anything else.

That happened LONG before the internal combustion engine, and even industrious man. :sad::sad::sad:

Enjoy.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,316
Messages
3,554,120
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top