I thought they should as well, I taped everything off and sprayed it with Rust-Oleum "paint for plastic".
I knew I liked the look so took my time and did it right the first time, and only one time..
I totally agree Toyota should've kept the black flares on the trail editions. Main reason I added the Bushwacker flares to mine. Some people don't like the aftermarket flares, and honestly I don't either on some colors, but I like the look on my magnetic grey.
If I didn't buy the aftermarket flares, I would probably go the route of plastidip if you aren't 100% sold on the look, or remove them and paint them if you are completely sure you want the look.
Thanks, I love they way my truck looks now.
The painting was quick, it was the prep that took half the day. I used playing cards.
how did you take the existing flare off and new ones on? did you have to get new clips? same goes for the folks that plastidipped the fendersI'm using OEM factory unpainted flares with a 3m clear bra over them