brian2sun
Elite Member
I went to Geico, and it was much cheaper. On the order of 400 dollars every 6 months cheaper.
Why? No idea. Honestly. Each company uses similar data, but each usually has its own variable formula used to determine the qoute.
I'm guessing you probably got less coverage with Geico, like one of those 15/30 policies I mentioned earlier. Like anything else, you get what you pay for. And the rates really don't differ all that much between companies. The actuarial depts all use the same sort of math to calculate your "risk".
When you get a "deal" from an insurance company (unless you are combining home, auto, life, etc..), it's usually because they just cut your coverage in 1/2 and don't tell you why they were able to save you 1/2 off. And most people are ok with that because they aren't thinking about, "what would happen if I hit a $50K car instead of a $10K car?" at the time they sign the policy. But, just make sure your insurance is going to realistically cover the cost of replacing a modern car. Otherwise you will get sued and have your wages garnished to cover the difference.
Keep in mind, most rates for the same exact insurance only differs about 10-15% between companies (not the 50-60% they try to make you believe on their commercials). So when that killer rate from Geico seems too good to be true, it usually is.
...Just some thoughts from a former insurance salesman.